Op-ed: East Buffalo Needs Community-Driven Structural Investments, Not Fly-In, Fly-Out Charity | Civil Eats

Op-ed: East Buffalo Needs Community-Driven Structural Investments, Not Fly-In, Fly-Out Charity

East Buffalo is full of existing Black-led groups working to feed and care for its residents in the aftermath of the massacre. And they’ll be doing the same long after the news media has moved on.

Mourners light candles at a makeshift memorial outside of Tops market on May 16, 2022 in Buffalo, New York. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Mourners light candles at a makeshift memorial outside of Tops market on May 16, 2022 in Buffalo, New York. (Photo credit: Scott Olson, Getty Images)

People with full lives were going about the quotidian act of shopping for food when a white supremacist walked into the supermarket and shot 13 of them. Eleven of the 13 individuals shot were Black, and 10 people are dead. The mass murder happened in the heart of a Black neighborhood with few supermarkets. The news media has since picked up on this fact, and our research team—members of whom have written about food inequities in Buffalo, New York, for the last 20 years—is being bombarded with queries about food access in Black Buffalo.

We are appalled at the framing of these queries, which offer an exclusively deficit-based view of the neighborhood and overlook the work of individuals and organizations that have been working to strengthen the food system in East Buffalo. We agreed to write this reflection to counter the public and policy amnesia that engulfs the concerns of Black communities in Buffalo. The city’s Black neighborhoods need sustained structural investments, not fly-in, fly-out charity.

“The arrival of the Tops market in 2003 was itself the result of a sustained, decade-long fight by neighborhood residents for a full-service grocery store.”

More than 80 percent of Buffalo’s Black residents reside on the city’s East Side. This high concentration and isolation—which is why the shooter targeted the area—enables both acute and chronic violence against Black people, and it is the direct result of decades of discriminatory policies and practices. In 2020, an analysis by the Othering and Belonging Institute at University of California, Berkeley, ranked Buffalo as the 18th most segregated in a ranking of 119 cities.

This is segregation by design. For nearly a century, public and private institutions have worked to keep Black people from moving west of Main Street using tools such as zoning laws, restrictive covenants, public housing, and blockbusting. Public and private lenders also discouraged financial investments in Black neighborhoods east of Main Street, as evidenced by redlining maps dating back to the 1930s, which persist in new forms today.

The historic disinvestment in Black Buffalo established a food system best understood as food apartheid. Unlike the commonly used term “food desert,” implying a naturally occurring ecological setting, food apartheid emphasizes the structural conditions responsible for creating inequity. In 2008, we reported that Black neighborhoods in Erie County had 40 percent of the number of supermarkets compared to predominantly white neighborhoods even when the prevalence rates were controlled for wealth of neighborhoods.

In other words, racial patterns—not economic power—explained the spatial disparities. Opportunity hoarding in the regional food environment is visible as major national and regional retail chains co-locate in the wealthier, white areas of Western New York. For example, four major retailers—Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, Walmart Supercenter, and the regional favorite, Wegmans—are located within a 1-mile radius in Amherst, a first-ring suburb of Buffalo. Wegmans’ only store location in the city is located on the north-western edge, disconnected from Black Buffalo.

The chronic segregation in the food environment persists today. In a survey of households in seven East Buffalo neighborhoods, conducted by our team from 2021-2022 as part of the Growing Food Policy from the Ground Up (GFPGU) initiative, 80 percent of respondents identified supermarkets as their primary source of food. But, there was only one in the Masten Park neighborhood (Tops, the site of the shooting), and there are only three supermarkets in all seven neighborhoods that we surveyed.

An estimated 40,000 people in the seven East Buffalo neighborhoods live farther than half a mile from the nearest supermarket. In our GFPGU survey, 37 percent of respondents reported having no access to a vehicle (for food insecure respondents that number was 45 percent), making it especially difficult for them to buy groceries. Average roundtrip travel time for households using public transit was 61 minutes, not including the time spent shopping for food, trip planning, nor time spent waiting due to delays or missed connections, which automobile users do not have to account for. From our survey, 15 percent of households reported “unpaid rideshare” as their most likely transportation to a supermarket. Indeed, one of the individuals killed in the Buffalo Massacre, Heyward Patterson, was known to ferry residents without cars to Tops for grocery shopping.

The arrival of the Tops market in 2003 was itself the result of a sustained, decade-long fight by neighborhood residents for a full-service grocery store. Della Miller, who served on a committee to advocate for the grocery store, recalls selling fruits and vegetables on the sidewalk in protest. Until its closure in the wake of the massacre, Tops was an important food retail destination, not only for its material importance but also as a symbol of community agency and power.

Alexander Wright (front), founder of African Heritage Food Cooperative, and John Ashley Jones (back), volunteer. (Photo credit: Courtney Anderson, Slow Roll Buffalo)

Alexander Wright (front), founder of African Heritage Food Cooperative, and John Ashley Jones (back), volunteer. (Photo credit: Courtney Anderson, Slow Roll Buffalo)

Over the course of the last week, the Black community’s response has been swift and purposeful. A coalition of Black-led community organizations, which includes Black Love Resists in the Rust (BLRR), Feed Buffalo (FB), the African Heritage Food Co-op (AHFC), Urban Fruits & Veggies (UFV), Colored Girls Bike Too, (CGBT) and Black Monarchy (BM), is coordinating care for neighborhood residents. BLRR is documenting residents’ needs, and connecting them with food, mental health services, and other forms of care from partner organizations.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

UFV and AHFC, a food retail cooperative and farm, are delivering groceries to residents. Feed Buffalo and UFV, both of which have modest refrigeration capacity, serve as aggregation hubs for donations. Members of CGBT, a mobility justice organization, are delivering food by bicycle. Some partners, like BM, are raising funds to Feed East Buffalo, while others are providing backend coordination. Within short order, this community coalition—which is one of several—began moving food to residents throughout East Buffalo. This rapid, coordinated response would not be possible were it not for the long, deep, and caring relationships among people in the neighborhood prior to the tragedy.

“We are collectively doing everything we can, filling gaps, regardless of our organizational mission,” said Jalonda Hill, founder of CGBT. “Our explicit goal is to shift power and make systems change around how decisions are made in our community.”

The Urban Fruits and Veggies mobile market

The Urban Fruits and Veggies mobile market. (Photo courtesy of Urban Fruits and Veggies)

While East Buffalo continues to take care of its own, charitable donations are pouring in from around the country and across the world. When the media attention fades and the donations slow, however, thousands of residents in East Buffalo will still face food apartheid. Repairing food apartheid will require sustained investment in the community food infrastructure—not short-term or charitable solutions. Re-opening the Tops on Jefferson, while necessary, is simply not enough. East Buffalo needs food-based economic development that provides infrastructure and generates intergenerational wealth.

This looks like full-service supermarkets (note the plural), farmers’ markets, cold storage facilities, value-added food processing facilities, aggregation hubs, community gardens, commercial and community kitchens, food-based incubators, and community-owned land trusts for urban farming. To counter structural racism in the food system, food-related infrastructure must be designed, owned, and operated by East Buffalo entrepreneurs, with dividends that go back to East Buffalo.

“Buffalo’s philanthropic organizations have for far too long funded outside organizations to serve East Buffalo; it is time to engage in reparative philanthropy and public policy.”

Failure to invest in community-owned food infrastructure will continue the trajectory of extractive development that has preyed on these neighborhoods for decades. A focus on short-term food charity masks structural racism in the food system itself, and, more broadly, in society. No quantity of food donations by outsiders is going to end structural racism. But sustained investment in Black-owned, East-Buffalo-owned food businesses and organizations that serve healthful, affordable, and culturally relevant foods is a step in that direction. Tackle structural racism in all sectors—public, private, and not-for-profit sectors—and food equity will follow.

Some of this is already taking place. For example, the AHFC has a capital plan for a brick-and-mortar location to house its operations. Their motto is: “Anything less than ownership is unacceptable.” UFV, which is led by Allison DeHonney, has plans to expand its urban farming operations into a health and wellness campus. Feed Buffalo aspires to launch a community food center, and Buffalo Freedom Gardens aims to provide all East Buffalo residents with backyard or front yard gardens. Those interested in investing should focus on these and similarly situated Black-led community organizations that have the vision, knowledge, experience, and relationships to build community food infrastructure in their own communities.

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

Rendering of the proposed Urban Fruits & Veggies wellness campus.

Rendering of the Urban Fruits & Veggies health and wellness campus. (Photo courtesy of Urban Fruits and Veggies)

Buffalo’s philanthropic organizations have for far too long funded outside organizations to serve East Buffalo; it is time to engage in reparative philanthropy and public policy. Local governments can support the right efforts through complementary anti-racist public policy investments in community food infrastructure. For example, Buffalo’s city government can reapportion its police budget to reinvest in East Buffalo community food infrastructure following examples reported by local governments elsewhere. (The Austin-Travis County Food Policy Board and Food Policy Council of San Antonio is a good example.)

City governments can decode and streamline public policy to make public resources accessible for East Buffalo residents and businesses. Access to vacant land for Black and other growers of color should also remain front and center in public policy efforts. City governments’ definition of what constitutes the highest and best use of urban land is that which promotes East Buffalo residents’ well-being, not that which enables profiteering by private developers.

Ultimately, all public and private investments in community food infrastructure must be guided by the intent to end structural racism. Until that happens, people will continue to use well-meaning food-related initiatives to mask and redirect attention from the problem at hand in Buffalo and the nation at large: white supremacy.

The authors are a group of interdisciplinary scholars from varied institutions affiliated with the UB Food Systems Planning and Healthy Communities Lab with a collective commitment to food justice in East Buffalo. The authors of this op-ed are: Emmanuel Frimpong Boamah, University at Buffalo; Enjoli Hall, MIT; Gabby Headrick, Johns Hopkins; Cameron Herman, Buffalo State College; Yeeli Mui, Johns Hopkins University; Carol Ramos Gerena, University at Buffalo; and Samina Raja, University at Buffalo (Dr. Raja is the corresponding author: email sraja@buffalo.edu) Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

More from

Commentary

Featured

Popular

Co-Op Grocery Stores Expand Their Mission to Equity and Food Justice

Detroit People’s Food Co-op Board Member Malik Yakini at the Detroit Food Commons construction site.

Native Tribes Are Bringing Prairie Land Back to the Pacific Northwest

A group sows camas seeds on the Jamestown Tribe’s 1.5-acre prairie site. (Photo credit: Miranda Wilson)

Top Chef’s Gregory Gourdet on Sourcing, Sobriety, and Equity

Gregory Gourdet in the dining room of his new Haitan restaurant Kann, which opened in August. (Photo credit: Zack Lewis)

Can an Urban Farm Run by Police Create Jobs, Feed People, and Build Trust?

A tractor and a podium at the unveiling of the Alameda County Sheriff's Office unveiling of the Dig Deep acquisition of Ardenwood Farm. (Photo credit: Joy C. Liu, Alameda County Sheriff's Office)