Op-ed: The Monarch Butterfly Emergency Unfolding Before Our Eyes | Civil Eats

Op-ed: The Monarch Butterfly Emergency Unfolding Before Our Eyes

Pesticides, climate change, and habitat destruction have put North American monarchs in a freefall. A proposed bill might help save them—but only if Congress acts quickly.

monarch butterflies on a tree

If you were in California this winter, you may have noticed something missing: the monarch butterflies.

Two decades ago, more than 1 million would arrive in California every winter, clustering on branches in colorful bunches and lighting up the coastal air with their delicate flights.

To see a kaleidoscope of butterflies is to witness one of nature’s most vivid migratory spectacles. A century ago, one California newspaper described a grove of trees with branches breaking under the weight of the western monarch butterflies overwintering in the area. The monarchs, “all twinkling in shade and sunlight, seemed the personification of happiness,” the observer wrote.

Now, monarchs are the personification of something darker, as a species that generations of school children once reared in classrooms in lessons of science and wonder, could soon be gone. This year, only 1,914 were counted overwintering in coastal California. There are more Starbucks locations in California than overwintering monarchs.

 

North American monarchs, famous for their 2,000-mile annual migrations, are in a freefall. Without help, the western population will almost certainly disappear this century. The eastern population of monarchs, which migrate across the country’s midsection and overwinter in Mexico, is in much the same dire straits.

Stepping back, this decline is no surprise. Since the 1990s, North America’s monarchs have lost about 167 million acres of their summer breeding habitat to agricultural intensification and suburban spawl. Milkweed, the monarch caterpillar’s only food source, has been nearly eradicated from the parts of the Midwest where they were typically born.

The widespread adoption of corn and soy crops that have been genetically engineered for herbicide tolerance has led to a dramatic increase in the use of glyphosate, dicamba, and other herbicides, and has likely wiped out billions of milkweed plants. Large areas of monarch breeding habitat are also planted with cotton, wheat, and other crops treated intensively with pesticides.

Monarchs are also threatened by neonicotinoids and other systemic insecticides used in agriculture, parks, yards, and commercial properties. Neonics are also now one of the preferred or most readily available insecticides used in conventional agriculture, especially for corn, soy, wheat, and other crops. On average, nearly 56 percent of the total planted acres for these crops are treated with such chemicals.

The climate crisis, too, has played a role. It is undermining the stable weather conditions and predictable flowering seasons that monarchs need to complete their migration. Climate change also threatens these butterflies’ overwintering habitat in the mountain forests of Mexico. Just as the Joshua Tree National Park will soon no longer support Joshua trees, the International Monarch Biosphere Reserve in Mexico is expected to become climatically unsuitable for monarchs by the end of the century.

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

The results of these combined changed have been catastrophic. Overall, monarchs’ numbers are down 80 percent in the past two decades, and more than 99 percent among those who overwinter in California.

These butterflies are in a state of emergency for and it’s time to respond. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service must protect monarchs by immediately placing them under the Endangered Species Act. In response to a 2014 petition from the Center for Biological Diversity and the Xerces Society, the agency said in late 2020 that protection may be warranted—and then put them on a waiting list.

These kinds of delays too often prove deadly. Indeed, 47 species have gone extinct while waiting for federal protections to kick in.

If we wait, the monarch population will continue to plummet, along with the populations of many other butterflies and bees. The loss of these crucial pollinators will not only threatens our global food security, they will leave a hole in the food web as a number of animals eat monarch eggs, caterpillars, and adults.

Congress should also spend $100 million on monarch conservation. That’s the least we need to cover the cost of restoring one million acres of milkweed and pollinator habitat per year. This will help the butterfly be more resilient to threats from habitat loss, pesticides, climate change, and severe weather.

Landowners and farmers can also play a strong role in this effort by planting milkweed and other pollinator friendly plants in non-cropping areas such as grazing lands, field margins, and yard and garden areas.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

In addition, the recently introduced Monarch Action, Recovery and Conservation of Habitat Act of 2021 (“MONARCH” Act) would provide $12.5 million a year to support on-the-ground conservation projects to stabilize and save the western population of monarch butterflies.

By advancing these measures, along with a concerted effort to protect the migratory pathways of monarchs, we can start pulling them back from the brink of extinction. Congress and the Biden administration must do right by monarchs, and act boldly and quickly.

Otherwise, we risk allowing monarchs to slip through our fingers and vanish forever.

Stephanie Kurose is a senior policy specialist with the Center for Biological Diversity. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. THEROOTMATTERS
    I KNEW SOMETHING WAS GRAVELY WRONG...

    Last year the tall, plush, woody bush located just to the left of my kitchen window, here in Central Valley California, was alive with swarming Monarchs. The bush was as full of Monarch Butterflies as the photo used at the heading of this article. Regal joy!

    This year I have not seen a single Monarch. My yard is full of multicolored flowering plants and verdant bushes. Hummingbirds, teensy bees, butterflies flit all about, YET, obviously missing amongst, the all too short visit when the Monarchs arrive. So sad...
  2. Lisa in Seattle
    Thanks Stephanie for this article. I will contact my senators.
  3. Helen McGinnis
    I moved to north-central West Virginia in 2001. There are a lot of milkweeds on my property and for the first few years, I recall seeing many monarchs and their caterpillars. Recently there have been few, but I've found two pupae, months or even a year old, filled with fluid. Could disease be a problem also?
  4. Incogmachito
    As long as Monsanto provides Round-up, butterflies and honeybees will die. Stop using poison on crops and gardens, lawns, etc.

More from

Commentary

Featured

Popular

As the Climate Emergency Grows, Farmworkers Lack Protection from Deadly Heat

Farmworkers pick bok choy in a field on January 22, 2021 in Calexico, California. President Joe Biden has unveiled an immigration reform proposal offering an eight-year path to citizenship for some 11 million immigrants in the U.S. illegally as well as green cards to upwards of a million DACA recipients and temporary protected status to farmworkers already in the United States.(Photo by Sandy Huffaker/Getty Images)

These Garden Mentors Are Growing Equity

Share a Seed Founder Reana Kovalcik (right) chats with Erin Palmer, ANC 4B02 Commissioner. (Photo credit: Hannah Packman, Slow Food DC)

LGBTQ+ Farms to Support this Pride Month—and All Year

Emily Fagan and Hannah Breckbill (photo courtesy of Humble Hands Harvest; Pride flag background CC-licensed by Benson Kua on Flickr)

34 Noteworthy Food and Farming Books for the Summer of 2021

a collage of the best food and farming books in summer 2021