Can Organic Farming Grow in New York’s Fertile Black Dirt Region? | Civil Eats

Can Organic Farming Grow in New York’s Fertile Black Dirt Region?

The Chester Agricultural Center is helping beginning farmers seed successful, diversified organic farms in fields formerly used for commodity onion production.

Dig Inn Farm at the Chester Ag Center. (Photo credit: Nico Schinco)

As farmer Shayna Lewis made her way out to one of Dirty Boots Farm’s three fields to pick okra, she used her bucket to push aside knee-high weeds creeping into the path.

“Don’t fall in the ditch,” she called out to a reporter crossing a thin wooden plank bridge supported by inky, sticky soil. Within minutes, two of the biggest challenges of farming in the Black Dirt region of Orange County, New York, were on display: weed pressure and flooding.

For the past several decades, most farmers in the region about 50 miles northwest of New York City have dealt with the first of those challenges by using chemical herbicides. Now, an initiative to convert about 200 of the acres of the famously fertile soil to organic production—to improve environmental outcomes, benefit the local community, and help beginning organic farmers get started—is trying to change that.

The Chester Agriculture Center (CAC) in Chester was created in 2014 when a local family foundation acquired nearby land. It is currently home to seven small organic operations, including Dirty Boots Farm, Sun Sprout Farm, Rise & Root Farm, and Dig Inn Farm. Where a large, chemically treated onion farm once flourished, now a diverse plethora of organic vegetables—from tomatoes, basil, and greens to fairytale eggplant, okra, and cardoons—is being harvested.

Laying plastic on the Black Dirt in Chester, N.Y. (Photo credit: Skinner Photography)

Laying plastic on the Black Dirt in Chester, N.Y. (Photo credit: Skinner Photography)

While its proximity to city markets gives the operation a financial leg up, challenges still abound. Nevertheless, could this project serve as a model for how to help a new generation of farmers committed to sustainable practices succeed in other locales?

Black Dirt Background

“What we’re farming is basically a giant bowl of compost,” says Cheryl Rogowski, a legend of organic farming in the Black Dirt region. Owner of Rogowski Farm, Rogowski is a third-generation farmer and the winner of a 2004 MacArthur “genius grant” for her work developing the area’s food system. (While Rogowski uses organic practices, her farm is not certified organic.)

In referencing compost, Rogowski was talking about the concentration of organic matter in the soil—which experts say is typically between 30 and 50 percent but can approach 90 percent in the region, making for incredible fertility. If typical soils are milk chocolate, the black dirt is 90 percent cacao, special dark—in terms of both jet-black color and nutrient-density.

Most of the 26,000 acres of Orange County’s black dirt, including Rogowski Farm, are in a section of the town of Warwick called Pine Island, but patches of the dirt, like the parcel in Chester, are spread out in neighboring towns.

For a long stretch of history, the fertile soil was hidden in swampland. In the 1800s, settlers figured out how to drain the water from the fields, and Polish and German immigrants began farming it. Pungent onions grew particularly well in the area thanks to the soil’s high sulfur content, and the region became a hotbed of commercial onion production in the second half of the 20th century.

Spring at Chester Ag Center. (Photo courtesy of Chester Ag Center)

Spring at Chester Agriculture Center. (Photo courtesy of CAC)

“In the beginning, all of the farms around here were organic, because no one had chemicals; then everyone went the other way,” Rogowski says. “But there’s more interest in organic now.”

Transitioning Land

That interest encouraged Guy Jones, a farmer who shares Rogowski’s stature as a pioneer of organic agriculture in the region. Jones owns Blooming Hill Farm in nearby Blooming Grove and also grows vegetables on the black dirt in Chester.

When Jones heard the conventional onion farmers surrounding his land were looking to sell, he began reaching out to people in his network to see if anyone would be interested in buying it and converting it to organic production.

That’s when the Ralph E. Ogden Foundation stepped in. The small family foundation supports various social justice and human rights causes in the area, and it had a growing interest in food and agriculture issues. (Local philanthropist Ralph Ogden, who died in 1979, co-founded Hudson Valley’s Storm King Arts Center.)

In 2014, the foundation purchased the former onion farms and established the Chester Agricultural Center with a mission to preserve and revive the black dirt using organic growing practices. It also aimed to support a new generation of farmers via long-term, affordable leases. The foundation later brought in eight additional investors.

Because the fertile land was all in one contained area, it seemed like an ideal parcel to work with. “We thought it would actually be possible to convert it all to organic and not worry about drift and contamination, which you have in the rest of the black dirt,” says Beatrice Stern, Ogden’s granddaughter and the foundation’s president. “More than that, it’s right in the village [of Chester], so there’d be the ability to actually involve the village and possibly help with economic development. And when we saw the infrastructure, we saw there was also an opportunity for programmatic work on food sovereignty, hunger, education, research on how to do organic in the black dirt—all of those things appeal to us as a foundation.”

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

With logistical help from Northeast Farm Access, CAC began offering 30-year leases to beginning farmers. “The idea was really to provide secure access to land,” Stern says, adding that those farmers had to commit to working the land a specific way. The leases include provisions like using organic practices and fair labor practices that ensure fair pay and housing for workers.

Farms in Action

Now, seven organic farms are fully operational on the land, with space for more. (CAC says it needs to expand its infrastructure before bringing on more farmers.)

Rise & Root Farm was founded by four New York City women, including food justice and urban farming advocate Karen Washington, the founder of Black Urban Growers. It sells its produce primarily at markets and to chefs in the city.

Rise & Root farmers Jane, Karen, Lorrie and Michaela. (Photo courtesy of Rise & Root)

Rise & Root farmers Jane, Karen, Lorrie, and Michaela. (Photo courtesy of Rise & Root)

Dig Inn Farm grows vegetables for its parent company, the fast-casual New York City restaurant chain Dig Inn, on 13 acres. During one week in August, farmer Larry Tse says he was harvesting about 1,000 pounds of tomatoes, 900 pounds of eggplant, and 2,000 pounds of chili peppers a week—to name a few standout crops.

Sun Sprout Farm started with a few acres of vegetables and flowers and has since expanded to 36 certified-organic acres.

Meanwhile, Dirty Boots Farm’s Lewis and her partner Matt Hunger are planning to lease an additional 3.5 acres next season to bring their farm up to nine acres. They sell via a CSA in Bushwick, Brooklyn, and through the app Farms2tables, which connects small farms with restaurant and institutional buyers in the Hudson Valley and New York City.

While the farms all operate independently, the farmers work side by side and share infrastructure including wash stations, refrigerated storage, and propagation greenhouses. This has led to a sense of community. “Having everyone here every day is amazing,” says Lewis, “especially because we’re experiencing the same conditions.”

CAC manager Lucinda Poindexter says that the Center wants to encourage more collaboration and knowledge sharing through events such as workshops, and it is also looking into other ways of supporting the farmers, like building out a commercial kitchen that would allow for on-site value-added processing.

More recently, CAC was able to secure a conservation easement, which means the land can only be used for agriculture in perpetuity. By taking the possibility of real estate development off the table, easements help keep farmland affordable.

Keeping Farms Afloat

CAC’s success ultimately depends on the ability of its farms to survive as businesses—and organic farming in the region comes with plenty of challenges.

One of the biggest being weed pressure. “We do have pesticides and fungicides we’re allowed to use, but there are no herbicides approved for organic, so our biggest expense is labor,” says Dig Inn farmer Larry Tse, “and here in the black dirt it’s kind of a losing game” when it comes to the never-ending fight against weeds.

Dig Inn farm manager Larry Tse in the field. (Photo credit: Nico Schinco)

Dig Inn farmer Larry Tse in the field. (Photo credit: Nico Schinco)

Farmers in the area who do use herbicides, Lewis says, have told her they face a similar uphill battle, but with the added cost of chemicals.

Thank you for being a loyal reader.

We rely on you. Become a member today to read unlimited stories.

Preventing flooding is also critical; one of the most important services CAC provides its farmers is overseeing a system of ditches that pump water out of the fields. Last summer was unusually rainy, and at one point, issues with the pumps prevented the water from draining properly. Lewis says one more day of rain would have led to the fields being completely flooded, decimating the crops.

Cheryl Rogowski, in fact, lost the original Rogowski family farm to foreclosure, after flooding caused by Hurricane Irene. Her fields were under water for three weeks, and she lost 80 acres of produce. She later relocated to a smaller plot of land.

Housing is another challenge. Property costs and rents in the region are high, and the farmers have struggled with securing affordable housing for themselves and their workers.

Finally, as with all beginning farmers trying to make small farms financially sustainable, it can be hard to find the proper sales channels. Some CAC farms sell at big farmers’ markets in Manhattan and to city restaurants, while others operate city CSAs. But trucking produce to the five boroughs is time-consuming and expensive, and selling to local buyers in Orange County has not been a reliable source of income.

Lewis works seven days a week during the growing season and has another job in the winter, when she also handles planning for the next year. Her partner also maintains another job. “Basically, I think the only reason it does work is because CAC is pretty flexible and you know, the bottom line is not the bottom line,” she says, referring to the organization’s flexibility.

Madeleine Banulski of Sun Sprout Farm harvesting in the high tunnel. (Photo courtesy of Chester Ag Center)

Madeleine Banulski of Sun Sprout Farm harvesting in the high tunnel. (Photo courtesy of CAC)

As CAC revs up to tackle ways it can foster the growth of more small, organic farms in the Black Dirt Region and beyond, those challenges will have to be addressed.

“We really see this… as a part of a network of people interested in changing the food system in the Hudson Valley,” the Ralph E. Ogden Foundation’s Stern says. She’s excited, for example, to work on more collaborative efforts with long-time organic farmers in the region like Rogowski and Jones and other organizations like the Hawthorne Valley Association’s Institute for Mindful Agriculture.

“It makes so much sense to collaborate because we’re learning all the time, and it makes sense to share it,” she says. “We really do see potential here to do… good for the local economy and for our farmers.”

Lisa Held is Civil Eats’ senior staff reporter and contributing editor. Since 2015, she has reported on agriculture and the food system with an eye toward sustainability, equality, and health, and her stories have appeared in publications including The Guardian, The Washington Post, and Mother Jones. In the past, she covered health and wellness and was an editor at Well+Good. She is based in Baltimore and has a master's degree from Columbia University's School of Journalism. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

  1. Daniel Raftery
    My wife and I have been getting our vegtables from Blooming Hill Farm for years now at the 2 markets in Ramsey. It’s great to see a big push to educate the public on organic farming. My one complaint is the understandably high cost of organic products.hopefully as organics become more popular and growing expands the prices will come down. Thank you.

More from




Senator Cory Booker Says FDA Proposal Could Worsen Antibiotic Resistance

A farmworker feeds cows in a barn.

Are Companies Using Carbon Markets to Sell More Pesticides?

a tractor sprays pesticides on a field while hazard symbols fade into the distance. (Civil Eats illustration)

In Brazil, a Powerful Law Protects Biodiversity and Blocks Corporate Piracy

An overhead shot of the Atlantic Forest in Brazil. (Photo credit: FG Trade, Getty Images)

Bringing Back Local Milk, Ice Cream, and Cheese

Foggy Bottoms Boys co-owner Cody Nicholson-Stratton pictured with his son. (Photo courtesy of Foggy Bottoms Boys)