Can Land-Based Fish Farms Solve Farmed Seafood Woes? | Civil Eats

Can Land-Based Fish Farms Solve Farmed Seafood Woes?

New contained aquaculture systems could bring local seafood to land-locked communities and change the industry in other important ways, too.

Family at Quixotic Fish Farm

Quixotic fish farmMore than half the seafood eaten globally is now farmed. And yet for some, aquaculture conjures up images of escaped fish, crowded pens, antibiotics, and ocean pollution in Asia, where nearly 90 percent of today’s aquaculture takes place. Now some entrepreneurs are bringing aquaculture on land. In the process, many hope to find a sustainable solution to the growing demand for a low-input, clean source of protein.

One of them is Tracey Carrillo, an agronomy professor at New Mexico State University. Carrillo initially started producing chemical-free shrimp as part of an experiment to see if they could be fed with organic cottonseed protein, an underutilized part of the cotton crop. When he had an abundance of shrimp on his hands, eager locals lined up around the block.Quixotic fish farm tilapia

“We’d send an email out to the college and the response was overwhelming,” he said. “[It was] the novelty of ‘Whoa, they’re growing fresh shrimp in the desert.’”

Carrillo’s shrimp are raised in a closed-loop system generally classified as a recirculating aquaculture system (RAS), which uses a beneficial and naturally occurring bacteria called biofloc to break down solids in the water. He helped to develop the system with the university’s Arrowhead Center technology incubator.

“It has taken us about four years to hone in on a system that we’re really happy with,” he said. “Any waste byproduct goes into a hydroponic system to fertilize vegetables.”

Aquaculture is the fastest-growing segment of the animal farming industry, according to the United Nation’s Food and Agriculture Organization. Global production has increased from 1.6 million tons of fish in 1960 to 66.6 million tons in 2012.

Yet much of the seafood grown in Asia and sold frozen in the U.S.—such as shrimp and tilapia—has been associated with unsustainable growing practices, such as high density pens, low-quality feed, and the use of antibiotics, which may contribute to the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria.

Shrimp is especially suspect, as recent investigations by The Guardian and Associated Press have shown that migrant workers from Burma and Cambodia have been trafficked to operate fishing boats and peel shrimp in processing facilities in Thailand. According to the AP, much of this shrimp was acquired by major U.S. supermarkets and restaurants, including Wal-Mart, Kroger, Whole Foods, Red Lobster, and Olive Garden.

Recirculating aquaculture systems on land could be a solution to many of these problems, as they can control what the fish eat, what they are exposed to, as well as their living conditions. That control will be needed if the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) follows through with its long-running plan to propose standards for organic farmed fish. They also allow more seafood production in the land-locked parts of the U.S. and they can also provide greater traceability.

Closed Systems, Big Business

“Recirculating aquaculture systems have the potential to revolutionize seafood production globally,” said Monica Jain, a seafood industry expert and the founder of Fish 2.0, an annual competition for sustainable seafood startups held in Silicon Valley where Carrillo competed recently.

Shortly after launching New Mexico Shrimp Company, Carrillo set up a second shrimp farm nearby, and sold a license to a couple that was interested in operating a franchise in Boston. Startup costs, Carrillo says, are between $60,000 to $100,000.

He hopes to establish franchises next in Denver, Dallas, Scottsdale, and Albuquerque. Buyers will receive a package that includes tracking software and technical support from the New Mexico Shrimp Company that will draw upon three years of farming data. The company will retain two percent of the licensed facilities’ gross profits every year.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

Recirculating land-based ventures have been springing up in other parts of the U.S. as well, such as a steelhead trout farm in Indiana and a startup in Maine that just received funding from the National Science Foundation to grow yellowtail for commercial sale in zero-waste fish tanks.

But there can be drawbacks and challenges this early on in the game. Recirculating aquaculture systems are energy intensive—and the energy they suck up is one of the primary costs of operation, according to the Monterey Bay Aquarium.

And entrepreneurs located in states with little regulations or policies in place might need to blaze their own path, as Carrillo found.

“It’s such a new industry that in New Mexico, they didn’t know how to address it in terms of permitting,” he said. “So their first response was, ‘You can’t do it.’”

Instead, the New Mexico Shrimp Company showed state agencies how they planned to raise the shrimp, and officials gave input on what they wanted to see, Carrillo said. Other states, such as Texas, Alabama, and Georgia have started to set policies for land-based shrimp production.

Randy Constant, a Missouri-based organic farmer, is further along, starting in 2010. “We realized that the oceans were being depleted at a rapid pace,” Constant said. “And we also knew that American healthy-minded households wanted to know where their protein comes from, what [the fish are] fed and how it’s handled.”

So when he came across a closed-loop tilapia operation in Colorado using RAS technology, he jumped at the opportunity to buy it.Quixotic fish farm

Now his company Quixotic Farming also raises tilapia in Missouri using the same technology—all without the use of chemicals or antibiotics. Constant says that the company can trace its product through records that document the living conditions of the fish every day before harvest.

Together, Quixotic’s two facilities produce over 1.2 million pounds of tilapia per year. The fish are sold in over 300 grocery stores across the U.S. “We still don’t have enough fish to meet the domestic demand,” he said.

Supporters say that land-based aquaculture won’t just benefit local consumers; the niche could also help decrease the pressure on global fisheries as the world population grows to 9.5 billion people by 2050. (That’s also part of the idea behind the newly approved but controversial genetically engineered AquaBounty salmon, which will be grown in closed, recirculating system farms as well).

Thank you for being a loyal reader.

We rely on you. Become a member today to read unlimited stories.

The interest in growing seafood on land has also spread to Europe, where Julian Connor, a commodities trader and CEO of Swiss Alpine Fish AG, is building a recirculating system in the Swiss Alps to raise Atlantic salmon.

“There are a lot of problems with salmon farms in the sea, such as chemicals, antibiotics, and fish waste falling to the ocean floor,” said Connor who was also at the Fish 2.0 event. His system—which Connor plans to get online by the end of 2015—will recycle fish waste into biogas at an onsite plant that will power the farm.

He has already sold 40 percent of the fish to Switzerland’s largest retailer. “I realized that the Swiss, more than people in any other nation, are willing to pay a premium for environmentally-friendly salmon,” Connor said.


Photos of an indoor tilapia farm courtesy of Quixotic Farming.

Kristine Wong is a multimedia journalist who reports on energy, the environment, green tech, sustainable business, and food. Her work has been featured in a number of publications, including The Guardian US/UK, The Huffington Post, Modern Farmer, TakePart and Sierra Magazine. Before becoming a journalist, she worked in community-based environmental and public health organizations for more than 10 years. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

  1. Crawford J. Willett
    I find this very interesting. the part about the use of fish poop to fertilize the crops. The use of land that is unfit for use as farm land. Solar and wind power can be used to power these aqua farms.
  2. Mary Mangan
    I think you should note that Monterey Bay Seafood Watch classes the Atlantic Salmon in recirc tanks as a "Best Choice". I think the way you left the note about them implies the wrong outcome of their assessments.

    But glad to see this coverage. Tom Colicchio demonstrated such an embarrassing failure to understand these systems in the NYT recently that he could really set back enviro benefits if he's not educated about it.
  3. Rusty
    There is nothing environmental nor sustainable about utilizing factory fish farms to combat our desire to over populate the world while depleting our sources of wild caught fish.

    Our problem is over population.

    There are reasons why consumer's are opting to buy pasture raised cows and chickens. The same holds true for fish that were never meant to swim within an enclosed pool that contain hundreds of their same kind with no diversity of any kind in their environment.

    If someone can read past the line that fish are being fed with organic cottonseed protein and no alarms and whistles are going off then I really fear for the future of the environmental movement.

    In short, wild fish belong in the wild and not a fish tank.
  4. Velo Mitrovich
    Off hand I can't think of a single RAS farm which has survived more than 3-4 years without government grants or fooled investors except for sturgeon farms raising fish for caviar. You'll never make a profit with RAS raising fish for food, it is an expensive gamble.
    At the end of the day, the problem with fish farming is the main species used, whether farmed RAS or in cages. Salmon, sea bass/bream, shrimp need fishmeal; tilapia and catfish don't; you need to change people's tastes.
    Mentioning shrimp and tilapia in the same breath is beyond comparing apples to oranges. Tilapia can be grown with zero fishmeal and indeed in some earthen ponds in east Africa they grow the fish on algae which is kick-started into growing with chicken crap.

More from



A farmer harvests coffee beans in a plantation along the Mekong River in Thailand. (Photo credit: Sutiporn Somnam, Getty Images)

Climate Solutions for the Future of Coffee

In the face of severe climate change, farmers, researchers, and coffee devotees are refocusing on agroforestry and developing hardier varieties and high-tech beanless brews to save our morning cup of Joe.


Far From Home, the Curry Leaf Tree Thrives

Zee Lilani of Kula Nursery stands among her curry leaf tree starts in Oakland, California. (Photo credit: Melati Citrawireja)

A Guide to Climate-Conscious Grocery Shopping

Changing How We Farm Might Protect Wild Mammals—and Fight Climate Change

A red fox in a Connecticut farm field. (Photo credit: Robert Winkler, Getty Images)

Across Farm Country, Fertilizer Pollution Impacts Not Just Health, but Water Costs, Too

An Illinois farmer fertilizes a field before planting. (Photo credit: Scott Olson, Getty Images)