Would you visit a meat packing plant with a viewing room?
X
Would you visit a meat packing plant with a viewing room?
March 17, 2015
The Vermont Packinghouse doesn’t have a single window on the outside, save on the front door of the main office. This is especially ironic, because the slaughterhouse has something unique on the inside: public viewing windows that allow visitors to observe how animals become food.
I peered through that office window when I arrived at the newly opened meat plant last fall, looking for managing partner Arion Thiboumery, but all I spotted were a couple of desks strewn with files. A few back issues of Meatpaper, the now-defunct Bay Area magazine for meat-loving hipsters, lay on a side table in the office, indicating this wasn’t your traditional slaughterhouse.
The office door was locked, so to find Arion I circled the entire building, which is located in a light industrial park in North Springfield and looks a little like a Soviet-era apartment complex. Around the back, I eventually found an unlocked door and stumbled into a small room next to the slaughtering floor—an area that in most meat plants is quite off-limits to visitors.
I spotted a sanitation worker who eventually found Arion, and the plant’s 33-year-old managing partner greeted me wearing bright yellow muck boots and a hair net. Arion makes up in charm for what the building lacks of it, and after greeting me cheerfully he took me on a tour of the plant and showed me what might be its most unique feature: the “glass walls.”
When a Minneapolis blogger described her 2010 visit to what is possibly the only other slaughterhouse in America with a public viewing window, Minnesota-based Lorentz Meats, she wrote: “The mood was sober and respectful, but stopped short of being either sad or sentimental.”
One person, she went on to write, was visibly shaken by seeing activity on the kill floor, but others were parents who brought their children along, “clearly intending for them to learn the whole story of where their food comes from.”
It’s no coincidence that Lorentz Meats and Vermont Packinghouse are the rare exceptions to the meat industry’s tendency to keep the general public out of slaughterhouses. Vermont Packinghouse is co-owned by Lorentz Meats, and Arion served as vice president of the Minnesota meat company before moving to Vermont to launch the Packinghouse.
The $9-million, 24-staff Vermont Packinghouse processes animals for Black River Produce (which owns the building and runs Black River Meats, a brand of New England-specialty meats), while also offering slaughtering and butchering services to local farmers who raise cows, pigs, lambs, and goats.
Uber-transparency is the norm at both the Vermont and the Minnesota facilities because the owners are serving customers of the 21st century local food movement, who expect openness about all facets of food production. Other Vermont slaughterhouses are open about their practices, too—but they don’t have windows.
“In a lot of the older plants in Vermont it would be hard to make a structural change like that,” says Chelsea Bardot Lewis, business development administrator at the Vermont Agency of Agriculture. But she adds that a number of local slaughterhouses would not turn away someone with a genuine interest in seeing their process.
Arion, for his part, used to be a self-described “do-gooder academic type,” having earned a PhD in rural sociology and sustainable agriculture with a minor in meat science, but he turned to more hands-on projects at Lorentz because, “At the end of the day, if new food systems are going to happen, people have to come in and run businesses.”
Especially businesses like slaughterhouses. They’re desperately needed by small-scale livestock farmers, but they’re the least understood and least attractive of places to the average local food consumer.
According to interviews conducted for a 2014 Vermont report on consumer valuation of meat processing, a handful of local meat professionals agreed that “consumers don’t want to think about the slaughterhouse, regardless of whether it is local or not,” and they’re definitely not interested in the details of animal processing.
But for those who want to observe it—an act that can require courage and vulnerability, but that can ultimately spark greater respect for animals, for meat, and for meat industry workers—Vermont Packinghouse quietly offers the opportunity, and with some degree of pride. Says Arion: “This is a clean facility, we’ve got good animal handling, and we’re committed to having people come here.”
Anyone who calls in advance or stops by during business hours can be let in to observe, through the two small windows, the process by which live animals become food: the quick shot that renders the animal desensitized to pain; the hoisting of the animal by its legs, so it can bleed out; the splitting of the carcass; the removal of the hide and the insides.
No animals were being slaughtered on the first day I visited, but on a second visit I watched a large veal calf from Lisa Kaiman’s Jersey Girls Farm going through the process.
It took less than 30 seconds before the kill floor foreman, Cory LaCroix, managed to quiet the animal enough to place the captive bolt gun to its forehead and immediately desensitize it to pain. The animal did writhe, but Arion explained that this is because the cow’s cells and nerves in the individual muscles can remain active for two hours after death. (Workers confirm whether a stun was successful by touching the animal’s eye—if the animal doesn’t flinch, the stun was a success.)
The calf was then shackled by its hooves and hoisted upside down. As “Sweet Home Alabama” played on a radio, Cory and other workers bled out the carcass, split it in two, and removed the hide. Arion likes to say the Packinghouse uses “everything but the moo,” so the hide would go to JC Rendering out of New York State, the organs would be turned into offal, and everything else not given back to the farmer would be rendered and turned into pet food.
Outside, there are holding pens for the animals that were designed by Temple Grandin’s firm, so they meet the high standards that Grandin, a pioneer in humane livestock handling, has set. High walls and a horseshoe design keep animals calm as they walk through. The entire plant has been positively reviewed by Animal Welfare Approved.
When I asked Cory if it feels weird to have people watch him work, he said “Naw. This isn’t our first tour comin’ through!”
Indeed, since the plant opened last fall, the largest tours have consisted of a few dozen college students. Farmers also come to observe the facility where their animals’ lives will end.
“I want the best start for them and the best life and the best end—then I know I’ve done my job as a responsible farmer,” Lisa Kaiman told me. “So to find someplace that has also thought through that whole process is really important.”
Vermont Packinghouse isn’t the only new slaughterhouse on the Vermont food scene. At least four others have opened or changed ownership in the last five years.
According to Chelsea Bardot Lewis of the Vermont Agency of Agriculture, what the Packinghouse represents, with its state-of-the-art facility and close partnership with Black River Meats, is a statewide move toward greater collaboration between meat producers (the farmers and food companies) and meat processors (the slaughterhouse owners and butchers).
In Vermont’s small meat plants, Chelsea says, “processors are more in touch with what’s going on at farmers’ markets and what the end user wants, and producers are realizing there are skilled meat cutters across Vermont with whom they can create deeper partnerships. We’re definitely seeing greater professionalism and customer service.”
In the meantime, the daily work that goes into putting humanely raised, ethically slaughtered meat onto tables goes on, with all of it very much on display at Vermont Packinghouse.
As I left the small room where I had observed my first industrial slaughter, I spotted a small sign that said photography of the processing area was not allowed—which made sense. It’s always better to see new things with your own eyes.
A longer version of this post first appeared on Vermont’s Local Banquet. Photo by Meg Lucas.
March 30, 2023
In an excerpt from her new book, ‘Under the Henfluence,’ Tove Danovich discusses her ongoing fascination with chickens and the challenge of reconciling the backyard trend with today’s industrial practices.
March 20, 2023
Temple Grandin taught us a lot about cows. But she's one person. How can we know everything that traumatizes every individual of every farmed species? We can't. It's great that workers know about corneal reflexes. But what if someone misses a blink? Ensuring "good welfare" is a delusion. It's more humane, and respectful, to simply stop using animals.
We have had many chefs, schools, Tufts university and farmers tourt the facility. We too believe in openness, education and transparency and are a family owned business that has been in operation for 49 years.
We cater hundreds of local farmers and the financing for the building of the new facility was all local money.
We also believe in honesty about sourcing product, honest labeling and supporting our local farming community, rather than importing product from PA.
Here's to the next 50 years of safe, human and transparent slaughtering of animals, where there is always a welcoming face at Adams Farm.
I work in a poultry slaughterhouse myself, and have frequently seen how after death especially big roosters keep moving around (and rabbits even moreso).
Everyone always makes this same statement, that it's "just nerves". While I'm sure they're right after a fashion, I personally have to wonder: isn't it "just nerves" that feel pain in the first place?
Ultimately, there is nothing humane about killing animals for food, especially when it is now well-proven, nutritionally and scientifically that eating animals can cause cancer, diabetes, strokes, heart disease, arthritis, Alzheimers, dementia, lupus, gout, erectile dysfunction, osteoporosis, and a host of other debilitating and deadly diseases. And raising animals in any conditions for consumption is the leading cause of environmental collapse.
The time has come to stop the madness of killing others for our pleasure, profit, and gain, which is evil according to author, psychologist, and Christian M. Scott Peck, who wrote The Road Less Traveled. Good people don't harm animals.
A plant-based diet is the only kind and civil diet.