Seeds: The Heart of Organic Innovation | Civil Eats

Seeds: The Heart of Organic Innovation

The Seed Matters project is investing in bridging the organic seed gap.

Seed Matters director Matthew Dillon (left) and Seed Matters organic bar...Matthew Dillon learned a tough lesson about seeds early in his career. Dillon was the executive director of the Abundant Life Seed Foundation at the time. The former organic farmer says he had become “obsessed with heirloom conservation and the importance of conserving genetic diversity,” and had spent time building the Foundation’s seed bank. Then one day, Abundant Life’s office—and seeds—was ruined in a fire. Over 5,000 rare plant varieties went up in smoke.

For Dillon, who went on to direct the Organic Seed Alliance (OSA), and now heads the Seed Matters initiative of the Clif Bar Family Foundation, the lesson was clear: Squirreling away the makings of genetic diversity in seeds banks isn’t enough.

“In order to have long-term resiliency, we need resilience in our seed systems, meaning regional farmers with strong seed skills, who know not only how to save seed for their own on-farm use, but how to continually improve crops and breed brand-new crops,” says Dillon.

His work is still based on this principle. In the last few years, Seed Matters has been working quietly, bringing on a sizable list of corporate partners, including Earthbound Farms, Whole Foods Market, and others, to do what it calls “Seed CPR,” by injecting $1.5 million into organic seed breeding, research, and production.

An entire sub-industry has sprouted up in recent decades selling seeds and plant starts. As a result, few of today’s farmers know how to save and work with their own seed and centuries of traditional knowledge has all but disappeared. In response, Seed Matters is training organic farmers to re-engage with this aspect of their work, with the hope that they will also find ways to improve the foods we eat.

They partner with OSA to do on-farm breeding and encourage farmers to develop new varieties, like Abundant Bloomsdale spinach, which is open-sourced (meaning it can be bred and shared openly by farmers), designed to grow espspinach-abundant-bloomsdale-fieldmarkerecially well on organic farms, and just went on the market.

In 2011, Seed Matters started graduate fellowships, focused on organic seed breeding, with the hopes of creating the next generation of researchers. Since then they’ve funded 13 fellows working on a range of topics.

Take Bill Tracy, professor and chair of the Agronomy Department at the University of Wisconsin in Madison who is working to improve sweet corn for organic farmers. The idea, explains Dillon, is to breed corn seeds that can survive being planted in early spring, when the soil is wet and cold. Conventional sweet corn growers buy seed that has been coated with fungicide, whereas organic growers don’t have, or necessarily want, that option.

Although Clif Bar, the company, has also provided funding for Seed Matters (they fund Dillon’s position as the director, and he also serves as the company’s agricultural policy and senior manager), the goal has never been to develop more organic ingredients for Clif Bars.

Rather, Dillon says, “we wanted to improve crops that we were hearing from regional farmers and plant breeders needed work. For example, we heard that farmers were concerned about organic corn being contaminated by GMOs, so we funded Major Goodman at North Carolina State to breed an organic corn that can better reject GMO pollen.”

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

That said, Dillon does point to the fact that Clif Bar was inspired by the work of Seed Matters to begin funding organic oat research as a company.

This year, after working more or less behind the scenes on an aspect of the food system that is essentially invisible to most eaters, Seed Matters will be launching a consumer-facing campaign to get people who Dillon says “already understand the farm-to-table,” to start seeing seeds in the equation. Call it seed-farm-table.

Dillon will be delivering a keynote at next month’s Organicology conference in Portland, Oregon, where he hopes to encourage the organic industry to step out of what he calls “its own mythologies.”

“Organic farming really isn’t farming like your grandpa used to,” Dillon says. It’s not just “cutesie little boutique farms doing a couple acres of rutabaga and kale. There’s a much bigger picture out there; organic has the potential to be a major catalyst for positive change and the ecological impact as well as improving the quality of food for consumers.”

He sees seeds as a great place to start with that innovation. But beyond that, he adds, “it’s a symbolic emblem of what we can accomplish in organic.”


Photos, from top: Matthew Dillon and Brook Brouwer, a Seed Matters fellow, courtesy of Clif Bar Family Foundation.  “Abundant Bloomsdale” spinach courtesy of the Organic Seed Alliance. 

Thank you for being a loyal reader.

We rely on you. Become a member today to read unlimited stories.

Civil Eats is a media sponsor of Organicology. The site has also received support from the Clif Bar Foundation.


Twilight Greenaway is the former managing editor and executive editor of Civil Eats. Her articles about food and farming have appeared in The New York Times,, The Guardian, Food and Wine, Gastronomica, and Grist, among other. See more at Follow her on Twitter. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

  1. Rita Stillman
    Thanks for all your efforts
  2. Joanna
    All I ever hear is the GMO GMO. This is what I call positive. You guys are making things right, like it should be in this primary industry. Awesome work guys.
  3. Bill Crabtree
    There are lots of farmers across Australia who preserve the old wheat varieties, and there are institutes that conserve thousands of species of seeds. It would be nice to have the option Joanna of some GMO technology included into varieties, but fearmongering, without foundation, on this has stopped progress and made the tech way too expensive. Indeed, this technology could reduce our reliance on fossil fuels and pesticides. Suggest folks listen to Robert Saik's recent TED talk.
  4. Gail Johnson
    Just want to say THANK YOU !!!!

More from




Zero-Waste Grocery Stores in Growth Mode as Consumers Seek to Ditch Plastic

Inside a re_ grocery store in the Mar Vista neighborhood of Los Angeles. (Photo courtesy of re_grocery)

On Farms, ‘Plasticulture’ Persists

Rows of plastic-covered strawberry plants.

Oral History Project Preserves Black and Indigenous Food Traditions

Ira Wallace (left) and Sariyah Benoit sit together in Spelman College’s Victory Garden. (Photo credit: Heirloom Gardens Project)

Can AI Help Cut Plastic Waste From the Food System?