A More Humane Way to Breed Laying Hens | Civil Eats

A More Humane Way to Breed Laying Hens

While many conscientious eaters go out of their way to purchase pasture-raised eggs laid by happy chickens, it’s a little-known fact that almost all eggs have a hidden cost: millions of baby male chicks are killed each year at the hatcheries that raise egg-laying hens. Even humane, organic egg producers are reliant on these large hatcheries.

“It’s a dirty little secret, isn’t it?” says farmer Nigel Walker of Eatwell Farm in Dixon, California, who has ordered thousands of Production Red chicks each year for his diversified organic farm. “Many customers have asked me about this practice and I’ve been very truthful with them,” he says. “I’ve always been uncomfortable with it, but I wasn’t able to find a good solution until now.”

Eatwell Farm recently launched a crowdfunding campaign on the online platform Barnraiser to start a chicken breeding program, which aims to eliminate the farm’s reliance on hatcheries. “We want to step up to the next level because we think it’s the right thing to do,” Walker says.

Live Fast, Die Young

Up until the last century, chickens were raised outdoors for the dual purpose of eggs and meat. Around the mid-20th Century, breeders began to focus on developing specialized breeds for indoor industrial production. “These birds are selected to live in a house with 25,000 other birds with constant light and heat all year round,” Walker says. “That’s not the environment we have in the fields.”

Popular meat breeds like the Cornish Cross have been bred for rapid growth, to the detriment of other characteristics such as longevity and disease resistance. “The average chicken in our country is processed [slaughtered] at 37 days,” says Jim Adkins, founder of the Sustainable Poultry Network in Old Fort, North Carolina. “If you and I grew at that rate, we would be 260 pounds by the time we’re two years old.”

Modern layers like the White Leghorn and Rhode Island Red are also bred for productivity: they lay 250 to 300 eggs a year. After about 14 months, they stop producing, making them virtually useless to a farmer, except for processing into chicken stock.

Because laying breeds don’t grow fast enough to be profitable for meat production, egg farmers have no incentive to raise the males, making them reliant on the hatcheries to replenish their flock every year. Once the chicks are sexed at the hatchery, the males are killed—ground alive, gassed or otherwise disposed of.

Out of the Hatchery

A couple years ago, Walker attended an Acres USA farming conference in Kentucky where he met Adkins, who opened his eyes to a different way of raising chickens.

A bird enthusiast and hobbyist who had raised more than 50 different breeds of chickens, ducks, geese, and turkeys, Adkins has seen all sides of the poultry industry. For several years, he was a supervisor at a large-scale turkey operation, where he witnessed the lack of sustainability of modern poultry breeding.  “I thought, ‘Something is wrong with this picture,’” he says.

In 2010, he founded the Sustainable Poultry Network, with the goal of restoring heritage breeds and training farmers to humanely and sustainably breed their own flocks. “We are on a mission to put the old breeds of poultry back to work,” he says. While such birds may produce fewer eggs and put on pounds more slowly than modern breeds, they tend to be more healthy, resilient, and productive in the long run.

Walker hired Adkins as a consultant to help him start a dual-purpose breeding program at Eatwell Farm. Eatwell is one of the largest operations Adkins has worked with so far, but interest is growing.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

“Nigel is definitely on the forefront,” says Adkins. “To be able to breed your flock so it’s sustainable is a lot of hard work.”

Starting from Scratch

For Eatwell, Adkins recommended the Black Australorp, a dual-purpose breed with dark, shiny feathers. Last spring, Walker bought 200 chicks (half male, half female) from a hatchery in North Carolina. When the Australorps arrived, they instantly took to the pasture and were more vibrant and alert than the Production Reds Walker was accustomed to.

Adkins chose seven males and 35 females to start the breeding families. “It’s a bit like heirloom tomatoes,” say Walker, who is well-versed in saving seeds. “You select the ones that do really well in your environment.”

As the flock grows, the birds must be carefully tracked. Each time a hen goes to lay an egg, a door closes behind her (in what is called a trap nest) so that the bird and her egg can be recorded by Eatwell staff. The best of the best will be selected for hatching.

With Adkins’ help, Walker hopes that Eatwell will be able to replace their flock of nearly 3,000 Production Reds within the next two years, possibly sooner, and the farm will no longer have to purchase chicks from hatcheries. Whereas the Production Reds lay for only about one year, the Australorps are productive for at least three. The males will be raised to maturity and processed for meat, providing additional income for the farm. Walker may also be able to sell his locally adapted Australorps to other farms in the area.

Raising the Barn

Completing such an ambitious project takes training, time, and money that is not currently in the farm’s budget. The $20,000 Eatwell is asking for on Barnraiser will help cover the costs of infrastructure, like incubators and nesting boxes, as well as labor and consulting fees. Pending additional funding, they hope to develop a mobile app to organize the breeding data and track flocks remotely, a tool that could be used by breeders across the country.

This is not the first time Walker has turned to his community for help in starting a new project. The farm originally set up its egg operation with financial help from his community-supported agriculture (CSA) members, who were demanding organic eggs. They quickly raised and loaned him $25,000, which he later paid back in full.

The income from Eatwell’s eggs barely covers the costs of production, but chickens play an invaluable role in the farm’s ecosystem, having eliminated the need for compost and external fertilizers.

Thank you for being a loyal reader.

We rely on you. Become a member today to read unlimited stories.

“The real core issue here is getting animals back on farms and out of these confinement operations,” says Walker. “Yes, we want their eggs, and the meat is great, too, but the reason we have our chickens is that they eat the pasture and fertilize the ground. All our organic vegetables are grown with fertility from cover crops and chickens.”

He continues, “We’re trying to find a bird that can live outside, where it can express all of its chickenness, but still lay a very reasonable amount of eggs and make an absolutely tasty roast chicken.”


A version of this post first appeared on the Center for Urban Education about Sustainable Agriculture (CUESA)’s website. To learn more about Eatwell Farm’s fundraising campaign, visit Barnraiser.


Brie Mazurek is Marketing & Communications Manager at the Center for Urban Education about Sustainable Agriculture, which operates the San Francisco Ferry Plaza Farmers Market. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

  1. Laura Beth Slitt
    Justifying the exploitation of other beings as "products" when there is not a single good reason to do so, is insane self deception and illogical. Humane? Nicer prisons?

    People are to easily convinced that , because atrocities have been happening and deemed, "normal" it's acceptable to continue them. That is a lie. There's NO requirement for the nutrients from eggs OR chickens in a healthy diet. Every single bird increases risk for mutating avian born viruses by one. Backyard chickens or factory farms, the fundamental problem is a human supremacist view of nature and animals that seeps into our relationship with other humans as well. Our domestication of others became the violence vector we must transform. Vegan ideology is peace
  2. Martha
    For the Vegan sister above I respectfully suggest she take a step back from her position and reconsider. A man by the name of Marcel Vogel confirmed through experiments that plants react with anxiety to the intention of another inflicting damage on them. Their energy systems react violently to the actual damage. And trees have been observed giving off electrical signals that sound like a scream when they are cut down. Until we can all live directly off sunlight, humanly and respectfully interacting with our food flora and fauna while they are still alive is an acceptable second place in my book.
  3. Jeanne West-Watanabe
    This is a fantastic article and I am so pleased to see that there is a better way to raise and do away with the current way the chicken industry disposes of male chics, which I just hate. Thanks for working towards this project. I wish you all of the best.

More from

Animal Ag



Zero-Waste Grocery Stores in Growth Mode as Consumers Seek to Ditch Plastic

Inside a re_ grocery store in the Mar Vista neighborhood of Los Angeles. (Photo courtesy of re_grocery)

On Farms, ‘Plasticulture’ Persists

Rows of plastic-covered strawberry plants.

Oral History Project Preserves Black and Indigenous Food Traditions

Ira Wallace (left) and Sariyah Benoit sit together in Spelman College’s Victory Garden. (Photo credit: Heirloom Gardens Project)

Can AI Help Cut Plastic Waste From the Food System?