Cookie Controversy! An Expert Weighs in on Food Waste and the Girl Scouts | Civil Eats

Cookie Controversy! An Expert Weighs in on Food Waste and the Girl Scouts

Thin Mints, Samoas, Peanut Butter Patties… Girl Scout cookie selling season is underway. This year, however, it kicked off with some unwanted controversy. No, not the hullabaloo about the Girl Scout who was rebuked for trying to sell cookies online. I’m referring to the ruckus that followed a CBS Los Angeles story that investigated what happened to 13,200 boxes of “perfectly fine” – not even expired – Girl Scout cookies. Reporter David Goldstein tracked the cookies back to the Girl Scouts of San Gorgonio Council in Redlands, California, and got video footage of a tractor crushing the boxes before they were sent to the landfill. A worker looking on joyfully cheered “Goodbye, Girl Scout cookies!”

According to the Washington Times, sources at the Girl Scouts of the USA office in New York stated that there isn’t an organization-wide policy for disposing of unsold cookies.

This controversy may change that, especially as awareness grows about America’s food waste problem (Between one-quarter and one-half of the US food supply is squandered each year).

To get a better insight into this cookie controversy and what it says about the state of food waste in the US, and the opportunity that it presents to the Girl Scouts, I contacted Dana Gunders, a Project Scientist at the Natural Resources Defense Council. Gunders, who has emerged as a national expert on food waste, recently authored an NRDC issue paper on the subject.

Dana, what can the controversy over the discarded boxes of Girl Scout cookies tell us about the US food waste problem?

That it’s more complicated than we think!  Here the Girl Scouts faced a problem almost all food companies know well – having to forecast what their demand will be. They would rather overestimate than fall short on their order so that they don’t lose a potential sale. There was even more incentive to overestimate because the supplier, in an effort to offer good customer service, was willing to take back unsold product. All the economics pointed towards erring on the side of more food, not less, even if some might get wasted.

The product could have been donated, of course, but that takes extra effort and sometimes brands don’t want their product donated for fear of liability or brand dilution. Limitations like this can and should be overcome, particularly when we have a federal law, the Bill Emerson Good Samaritan Act that protects businesses from liability for food donations.

Another interesting aspect of this story is that food banks may not have even wanted to receive those cookies. There’s a movement by food banks away from products high in sugar and fat in order to offer healthier food to those they serve, and some food banks no longer accept certain baked goods.

What can this incident tell us about the US and global food system?

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

Waste is deeply rooted within the economics of our food system. At the core, it makes perfect business sense for a business to reduce its own waste, but to try to sell as much as possible to those further down the supply chain – whether or not they need it. This is true for manufacturers like ABC Bakery, who encouraged the Girl Scouts to order more cookies by offering to take some back if they didn’t sell. It’s also true of our grocery stores, who aim to sell us as much as possible regardless of whether we actually will eat it. That’s why we need to be smart shoppers and buy only what we know we will eat each week.

This isn’t the first time Girl Scout cookies have come under fire. Does this situation present an opportunity for the Girls Scouts and their environmental stewardship efforts?

Absolutely! Just as the Girl Scouts took a stand against allowing palm oil in their cookies to contribute to deforestation, they can use this as an opportunity to raise awareness of the significant environmental impacts associated with wasting food. For example, throwing out just one hamburger wastes as much water as a 90-minute shower because of all the water it takes to produce that hamburger. The Girl Scouts are the perfect ambassadors to help themselves, their families and all of us respect what it takes to get food to our tables and reduce food waste across the country.

And just to make sure we end on a sweet note, what is your favorite Girl Scout cookie?

Hands down, it’s Thin Mints.  I grew up with a box in the freezer at all times (where they never go stale, by the way)!

This post originally appeared on the EcoCentric blog.

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

Photo credit to Marit and Toomas Hinnosaar.

Kyle Rabin Kyle Rabin is Director of Programs at GRACE Communications Foundation, where he is responsible for the coordination and operations of the foundation's ongoing programs and plays a key role in planning, organizing, staffing and leading a variety of program initiatives. His interest and expertise are in the areas of clean energy, water resource protection and the food-water-energy nexus. He is a regular contributor to GRACE's Ecocentric blog and has been published in the New York Times, Newsday, the Huffington Post, Civil Eats, AlterNet and Grist. He has been quoted in print media and has appeared as a guest on radio and television programs. He frequently speaks at state and national conferences. Prior to GRACE, Kyle was Executive Director at Friends of the Bay and was a Senior Policy Analyst at Riverkeeper. He began his work in the environmental arena as an Air and Energy Program Associate at Environmental Advocates of New York. Kyle received an MS in Environmental Science from the State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry and a BA in Environmental Studies from Binghamton University. Kyle and his family live in an energy efficient home, meeting half of their electricity needs with a rooftop solar electric system. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

  1. M.
    I work in a homeless shelter, and while we do try to be aware of nutrition in the foods we offer, boxes of Girl Scout cookies would absolutely be welcome!
  2. As a Girl Scout leader myself, I am troubled by the hypocrisy of the cookie business. Girls earn badges by learning how to engage in healthy behaviors, yet we have them out selling cookies. Our promise includes the words "use resources wisely," yet GSA does not practice this itself. Gah! What is the lesson here?
  3. Vermin F. Cockwolf
    No mention of the abhorrent ingredients? These cookies are some of the few products that still contain hydrogenated oils, and don't get me started on the high-fructose corn syrup. Our girls should receive an education about the abysmal state of our food supply and we, as a nation, deserve better than this!
  4. Rachel
    Seriously, my daughter is a Girl Scout and we refused to sell the cookies because they are full of GMOs (genetically modified organisms) so in other words my daughter is not going to push CANCER COOKIES on our friends and family and they don't get my money or get to come in my home...their cookies are not tasty treats, but a fast track to chemo! I wrote girls scouts about my hopes that they would look into reformulating the GMOs out of the cookies and they sent me the most limp response, extolling the virtues of GMO crops and how they will feed the world...straight out of Monsantos play book. I really did not take them for being so easily mislead...they must have been eating their own cookies!

More from



Ronald White (left) and Willington Rolle work in the Roots in the City urban garden in Miami's Overtown neighborhood on October 21, 2009 in Miami, Florida. The 2-acre lot, which was once a blighted area, features collard greens, citrus trees, papayas, and an assortment of vegetables. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

Op-ed: 4 Solutions to Make Urban Ag Policies More Equitable

Black Americans lack access to food and land—and city leaders often actively disrupt efforts to build food sovereignty. These policies could address the systemic injustices behind food apartheid and help urban ag scale up nationwide.


Farming in Dry Places: Investors Continue to Speculate on Colorado Water

cattle walking to a water trough in douglas county, colorado. Photo credit: thomas barwick, getty images

Changes to WIC Benefits Would Cut Food Access for Millions of Parents

a young parent feeds an infant food that they bought using their wic benefit

Supermarket Food Waste Is a Big Problem. Are Strategic Price Cuts the Solution?

avocados are on sale to prevent food waste using dynamic pricing at a supermarket

What the Rapid Rise of Norway’s Farmed Salmon Industry Means For the Rest of the World