Food Movement: Another “Sleeping Giant” Awakens on Immigration Reform | Civil Eats

Food Movement: Another “Sleeping Giant” Awakens on Immigration Reform

What do food banks, food chain workers, and Dreamers all have in common? The answer, when it comes to immigration, is just about everything.

Today, our misguided immigration policies prevent us from providing healthy and sustainable food for all families, from upholding basic standards of human and labor rights within our food systems, and from creating opportunities for healthy communities for all children. In fact, America’s food system cannot thrive without fair, just, and humane immigration reform.

If you care about food, then you’ll be cheering that after years of organizing and advocacy in immigrant and progressive sectors, immigration reform frameworks emerging from Washington include a path towards citizenship for undocumented immigrants.

Right now, no one knows the details contained in these proposals. Even so, we know we must build on this momentum to ensure that the massive public demand for immigration reform includes guarantees for immigrant worker rights and an end to detentions, deportations, punitive policies like Secure Communities, and other brutal enforcement policies. Such changes would go a long way towards ending the human rights abuses that our present food system is built upon.

The US industrialized agri-food system has always relied on cheap labor –- from indentured servants to slaves to recent immigrants — to ensure profits in an increasingly concentrated system. Low wages are coupled with poor working conditions and federal labor standards exclude workers in many sectors of the food system. Today, there are 20 million workers along the food chain in the U.S.; seven of the 10 worst paying jobs in the nation are food system jobs. In some industries more than half of workers are undocumented immigrants.

Immigrants who work in the food system, particularly those who are undocumented or with a vulnerable immigration status, are targets of human rights abuses, exploitation, and unfair labor practices. At worst, these workers experience modern-day slavery and sexual assault: in the last decade, for example, the Coalition of Immokalee Workers has helped prosecute 9 cases of modern-day slavery in Florida’s tomato fields alone. At best, immigrant food chain workers experience stagnant poverty-level wages. Along the vast spectrum from field to processing, packaging, distribution, and to table, abuse and low-wages abound.

The Food Chain Workers Alliance 2012 report The Hands That Feed Us concludes that undocumented workers experience lower wages and greater wage theft than other workers in the food system. For example, from a survey of over 600 food workers:

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

  • Undocumented workers had a median hourly wage nearly 25% lower than all other food chain workers.
    Undocumented workers were over 2.5 times as likely to experience wage theft than other food chain workers. Among workers who experience wage theft, undocumented workers lost nearly 90% more than documented food chain workers.
  • Undocumented workers were over 2.5 times as likely to earn less than the legally required minimum wage.
  • When food workers are exploited and unprotected, they are likely less able to provide food for their own families and to protect the safety and quality of our food. Because of their low wages, food workers use food stamps at more than 1.5 times the rate of the general workforce in the U.S. and suffer food insecurity at 1.2 times the rate. The United Food and Commercial Workers union also found that between 2001 and 2009, food safety recalls were more likely to come from non-unionized meatpacking plants than from those that were unionized.

Not surprisingly, the growing and powerful food movement – from strawberry growers to Slow Foodies – is beginning to make the connection between food and migration. In the coming round of immigration reform, the emerging convergence of food and migrant justice may be another “sleeping giant” with the power to make a difference.

The recent Brandworkers victory in New York City offers just one example of the growing collaboration between immigrant food workers, food advocates, and food consumers. On May 7, 2012, workers at Flaum Appetizing and members of Brandworkers International, a workers center that organizes food processing and distribution workers in New York City, announced that they had won a global settlement that returned to them $577,000 in unpaid wages and other compensation, as well as subject Flaum Appetizing to a binding code of conduct protecting workplace rights. The victory came after the workers had won their claim against the company for unjustly firing them for organizing. The company had fought back, claiming they did not have to provide restitution to the workers because they were undocumented immigrants.

Local victories abound and are creating vibrant new connections between the food and immigration movements. For example, in October 2012, food justice, anti-hunger, labor, environmental, faith-based and food producer groups came together to launch the US Food Sovereignty Alliance. At its first national gathering, members chose immigration policy as one of the Alliance’s three priority areas. Most recently, a new collaboration between Food Chain Workers Alliance, the Food Labor Research Center at UC Berkeley, the National Network for Immigrant and Refugee Rights, and the Movement Strategy Center is compiling stories of immigrant food workers organizing for a voice on the job, immigrant communities fighting for access to affordable, healthy food, and food chain employers who know that genuine immigration reform is in their best interest. This article is the first in a series gauging the power of the food movement as it begins to realize its influence in the current immigration policy debate.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

Navina Khanna is co-founder and the Field Director of Live Real, a national initiative dedicated to amplifying the power of young people in frontline communities shaping radically different food systems through policy and practice. Based in Oakland, she’s worked as an educator, community organizer, artivist and policy advocate transforming local, regional, and national agri-food systems from field to vacant lot to table. As a Movement Strategy Center Associate, she applies lessons from other social justice movements to build a stronger, more aligned, and strategic food justice movement. Read more >

Joann Lo is the Executive Director of the Food Chain Workers Alliance, a national coalition of unions, worker centers, and advocacy organizations representing workers throughout the food system. Joann has over 16 years of experience in labor and community organizing and alliance-building. She is vice chair of the Leadership Board of the Los Angeles Food Policy Council and mom to two energetic young kids. Read more >

Catherine Tactaquin is Executive Director and a co-founder of the National Network for Immigrant and Refugee Rights. The daughter of an immigrant farmworker from the Philippines, she was involved for many years in grassroots organizing and advocacy in the Filipino community on issues of discrimination and foreign policy. She is a frequent speaker on topics ranging from global migration and human rights, to race and gender perspectives, and immigration reform. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Inelda Z. Gonzalez
    Even as a USA citizen born in the 1940's, our family followed the "crops" during the summer while my brothers, sisters, and I were not in school. The pay we received then, too, was not up to par, but we needed what we could get paid. BUT, that was in the 1950's! I cannot comprehend why those persons willing to work at such a low salary are being financially deprived of a better wage.
  2. As the article above points out the issues here are neither easy, nor simple. Last summer the organization that I work for, Farm Foundation www.farmfoundation.org and AGree www.foodandagpolicy.org/ cosponsored a symposium which brought together farmworker advocates, farmers and other stakeholders. As the summary of that meeting http://www.farmfoundation.org/webcontent/Future-of-Foreign-Born-Labor-in-U-S-Agriculture-1753.aspx reveals, the current system does not serve either farm workers or farmers well.

    But questioning minds should not stop at the near term issues posed by immigration policy. As I point out in a recent blog http://www.agchallenge2050.org/human-capital/2012/12/critical-need-for-a-strategic-industry/ there are even greater long-term challenges for agriculture in developing a workforce for the 20th century.

More from

Food and Farm Labor

Featured

Popular

Op-ed: The Pandemic Didn’t ‘End Hunger’—It Exposed Systemic Racism Instead

low angle view of african american man with scarf on face holding placard with racism is a pandemic lettering against blue sky

Methane from Agriculture is a Big Problem. We Explain Why.

a farmer looks at his beef cows and wonders how they produce so much methane.

How an Ancient Potato Could Thrive in a Changing Climate

digging up some four corner potatoes from the soil in utah

Did the First UN Food Systems Summit Give Corporations Too Much of a Voice?

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 25: Foreign Minister of Russia Sergey Lavrov addresses the 76th Session of the U.N. General Assembly at U.N. headquarters on September 25, 2021 in New York City. More than 100 heads of state or government are attending the session in person, although the size of delegations are smaller due to the Covid-19 pandemic. (Photo by Eduardo Munoz - Pool/Getty Images)