Pesticide Lobbyist Gets Posted as Chief Agricultural Negotiator | Civil Eats

Pesticide Lobbyist Gets Posted as Chief Agricultural Negotiator

Confident after his success with health insurance reform, President Obama exerted his executive power on Saturday by making fifteen appointments during the Senate’s recess. Among the appointments was Islam Siddiqui, who will now be serving as the Chief Agricultural Negotiator in the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative (I’ve written here about what that job entails).

Siddiqui had been working since 2001 as a lobbyist and then later as vice president of science and regulatory affairs at CropLife America, a lobbying organization for the pesticide and biotech industries. CropLife famously sent Michelle Obama a letter trying to convince her to use pesticides on her organic garden on the White House lawn. But while that move pushed the group into the media spotlight, behind the scenes the group in which Siddiqui has had a strong hand in leading has been lobbying to weaken regulations on biotechnology, pesticides and other agriculture chemicals both in the US and abroad, including securing exemption for American farmers in a worldwide ban of the ozone-depleting chemical methyl bromide in 2006, taking part in secret discussions with the Environmental Protection Agency to be allowed to test pesticides on children, and Siddiqui personally chided the European Union for “denying food to starving people” for using the precautionary principle in the case of GMOs.

While his nomination was held up for other, partisan reasons, over 80 environmental, consumer and farm groups opposed the nomination in a letter to the Senate Finance Committee, and tens of thousands of people called their senators and signed a petition in opposition. But as President Obama ramps up his effort to increase our exports in agricultural and other products abroad (which I critiqued here), he has sought a warm body to fill this position — and I’ve suggested before, a ‘bad cop’ to balance Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack’s ‘good cop’ abroad.

The Pesticide Action Network North America was one of the groups opposing Siddiqui’s nomination, and Senior Scientist Marcia Ishii-Eiteman had this to say about his posting:

It is unfortunate that many of President Obama’s nominations have been held up, largely due to partisan politics. But what President Obama seriously misjudged this weekend when he appointed Siddiqui without allowing a full Senate vote is that a huge swath of the American public is outraged at the idea of putting a former pesticide lobbyist in charge of US agricultural trade.

When 90,000 people petition their public servants (which is what Senators and the President are, after all) to say that a nomination is unacceptable, and that these revolving door appointments have to stop, and the President proceeds anyhow, what I see is a dereliction of duty. Expediency trumping democracy is how we end up with industry lobbyists running the regulatory agencies in the first place.

The forces protesting Siddiqui are not fringe, are growing, and will prove more powerful than I think President Obama wants to acknowledge. This March over 100 groups —including family farmers and farmworkers, anti-hunger, faith-based, sustainable agriculture, consumer and environmental groups across the country —wrote their Senators a second time, reiterating their opposition to this appointment in no uncertain terms.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

During his confirmation hearing, Siddiqui attempted to appease public criticism, claiming that he would include the views of both organic and conventional agriculture—but we know from his tenure at USDA that Siddiqui’s vision of organic farming includes use of toxic sludge, GMOs and irradiation.

Siddiqui also pledged to recuse himself for two years from taking part in decisions directly affecting his former employer. But this so-called “ethics pledge” does nothing to assure the American public that Siddiqui will value and protect the interests, health and livelihoods of family farmers, farmworkers, rural communities and urban consumers, over the interests of large multinational agribusinesses. Just about everything Siddiqui has said indicates his ongoing support for what is widely viewed as a failed model of agriculture that has led to dumping cheap and unhealthy agricultural products on consumers, polluting our air and water, and preventing small-scale and family farmers from being able to make a decent living.

What it comes down to is this: Both Siddiqui and Congress now face a well-informed and outraged citizenry as well as an unprecedented mobilization of public interest groups. The American public will be closely monitoring Siddiqui at his new job, and evaluating whether his actions will truly benefit small-scale family farmers in the US and abroad, workers, consumers and the environment—or whether they will benefit large corporations such as Monsanto, JPS, Cargill and Archer Daniel Midlands.

Siddiqui’s posting is a serious setback for those hoping for “fair trade” and for those who believed that President Obama had sustainable agriculture on his agenda. This Chief Agricultural Negotiator means business as usual.

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

Paula Crossfield is a founder and the Editor-at-large of Civil Eats. She is also a co-founder of the Food & Environment Reporting Network. Her reporting has been featured in The Nation, Gastronomica, Index Magazine, The New York Times and more, and she has been a contributing producer at The Leonard Lopate Show on New York Public Radio. An avid cook and gardener, she currently lives in Oakland. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

  1. As was reported last week in Western Farm Press, farmers are still considered vital to the US economy. Woo hoo! Bad news is that the $$ is from agricultural exports - $115.2 billion.
    Is that the real value of our farmers? Is that why we have an Ambassador of Pesticides now representing our interests?
  2. Robert Renner
    Well, there is now one vote that Obama will not have again. First Salazar and now this. It's too much!
  3. Nicole M.
    This is sickening. People wonder why conditions such as autism are on the rise-it's because we are all being poisoned. How could someone with such a conflict of interest be appointed to this position?
  4. Soi Disant
    My question is simple: I wonder how long in years it's going to be before growing your own garden in your own yard becomes, somehow, illegal.

    Far fetched? Some sort of left-wing paranoia? Perhaps.

    But then, ten or fifteen years ago, lots that is commonplace now, would have been difficult to conceive, yet here we are.
  5. Pro Organics
    What makes me ill is that the makers of pesticides are some of the same companies who create prescription drugs...a vicious circle of job security these pharmaceutical companies have created for themselves.

More from

Farm Bill



As Grocery Stores Get Bigger, Small Farms Get Squeezed Out

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - OCTOBER 13: Produce is offered for sale at a grocery store on October 13, 2022 in Chicago, Illinois. According to government data released today, the food at home index, a measure of grocery store prices, increased 0.7% in September from the month prior and saw a 13% increase over the last year. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Op-ed: Some Regenerative Farms Are Weathering California’s Unprecedented Rainfall

SANTA ROSA, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 09: In an aerial view, water floods a vineyard on January 09, 2023 in Santa Rosa, California. The San Francisco Bay Area and much of Northern California continues to get drenched by powerful atmospheric river events that have brought high winds and flooding rains. The storms have toppled trees, flooded roads and cut power to tens of thousands. Storms are lined up over the Pacific Ocean and are expected to bring more rain and wind through the end of the week. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

The Farm Credit Administration’s First Indigenous Chairman Wants to Level the Playing Field

Eldrige Hoy, left, and Bryson Sam, members of the Choctaw Nation, seed a high tunnel with Iron Clay peas as a cover crop to improve soil quality. (USDA photo by Bob Nichols)

Kristin Ohlson Wants Us to Reimagine Collaboration on the Land

Kristin Ohlson and the cover of her book, sweet in tooth and claw