Riots or Rebellions? Eric Holt-Giménez Looks at the World Food Crisis | Civil Eats

Riots or Rebellions? Eric Holt-Giménez Looks at the World Food Crisis

Eric Holt-Giménez, Executive Director of Food First/Institute for Food and Development Policy recently partnered with Raj Patel and Annie Shattuck to bring us Food Rebellions: Crisis and the Hunger for Justice. Recently, Holt-Giménez spent a weekend in New York to introduce his new book and open a conversation about these rebellions.

Perhaps you’ve heard the stats: between 2007 and 2008 approximately 40 food riots occurred around the world. In Mexico, corn prices made tortilla, a staple of the country’s diet, prohibitively expensive for the nation’s poor. In Haiti, soaring food prices led people to the streets, and eventually to overthrow the Prime Minister.

Yet were these riots or rebellions? For some, the distinction may seem small. These were not spontaneous anger outbursts fueled by mob mentality. They were not riots. Rather, they were conscious, political acts. They were rebellions. The objectives of a rebellion–agency and intention–are the essential implications of the word itself.  They are not just a reaction to food prices–they are a protest.

But a protest against what, exactly? The simple answer: against the causes of the food crisis. But Holt-Giménez draws an important distinction between what he calls the “proximate” and “root” causes of the global food crisis. It is the difference between symptoms and sickness.

Proximate causes are the commonly-cited reasons for hikes in food prices. These include grain speculation, increased use of land for agro-fuel production (as opposed to edible crops), increased meat consumption and a particularly poor harvest season in the US, Australia and Turkey. While in 2007-2008 these forces were certainly at work, a deeper look reveals that the food crisis was actually a long time in the making.

A more discerning analysis of the upheaval of 2007-2008 points to what Holt-Giménez calls the root causes of our food crisis. We have a vulnerable food system, one in which 91% of our crops are maize, cotton, wheat, rice and soy. A lack of diversity in our agricultural repertoire leaves our crops open to environmental (not to mention economic) shock.

newsmatch banner 2022

Think Irish potato famine.

Holt-Giménez sees our vulnerable food system as part of the “agri-foods industrial complex.” The agri-foods industrial complex actually refers to any and all corporate business involved in the production, processing, storing and transporting of food. It is a powerful force to reckon with. Follow its track record, Holt-Giménez urges, and one will see that the Green Revolution combined with the destruction of tariff barriers in the ensuing decades, and the free-trade trends of the 90s, were all results of a corporation-driven food system. These phases increased developing nations’ dependency on imported grain and seed, in countries that had been largely self-sufficient before. Production went down, diversity shrunk dramatically, local producers lost their market and were forced migrate–often emigrate. One million bankrupt Mexican growers, for example, headed for the United States.

There is a danger in conflating the proximate and root causes of the food crisis in searching for solutions, warns Holt-Giménez. When we focus only on the symptoms of the problem (grain speculation, increased agri-fuel production, lower crop yields) we easily reach the conclusion that genetically modified food and industrial agriculture present a “solution,” or an immediate fix to world hunger. Not so fast. Looking at the root causes, we see that loss of crop diversity, market flooding and farmer bankruptcy are actually all part of the quick fix that fuels the agri-foods industrial complex. It is the consolidation of land and power.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

We need our seeds and we need our small farmers. We need them not just for biodiversity, not just for distribution of power, but for the pure know-how they possess. There can be a place for small farmers and an alternative food system. As long as our planet has a smallholder population, we have a chance, Holt-Giménez argues, citing La Via Campesina as a hopeful example. Low-input, small operations can indeed be high-yielding. They needn’t be reinvented, just supported. We can’t use a corporate food system to fix symptoms of the corporate food system itself.

At the end of Holt-Giménez’s talk, he reminded his audience that we are political beings, even in the toughest circumstances. Our challenge now is to recognize sickness, not symptoms–and revolution, not riot.

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

Julia Landau is a program associate with Slow Food USA. She has worked with food and farming in the Hudson Valley and has served on the Board of Directors of the Poughkeepsie Farm Project. After spending the past year in Brazil, Julia now lives in Brooklyn, NY. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

More from

Farm Bill

Featured

Ann Tenakhongva, 62, and her husband, Clark Tenakhongva, 65, sort traditional Hopi Corn at their home on First Mesa on the Hopi Reservation in Arizona on September 28, 2022. The corn comes from the families’ field in the valley between First Mesa and Second Mesa, which Clark had just harvested. The corn is organized on racks to dry out and then stored in cans and bins for years to come. Much of the corn is ground up for food and ceremonial purposes. Corn is an integral part of Hopi culture and spirituality. (Photo by David Wallace)

Climate-Driven Drought Is Stressing the Hopi Tribe’s Foods and Traditions

Most Hopi grow corn with only the precipitation that falls on their fields, but two decades of drought have some of them testing the waters of irrigation and hoping they can preserve other customs with their harvests.

Popular

A Young Oyster Farmer Carrying on the Family Business

Gaby Zlotkowsky on a boat holding a basket of oysters. (Photo credit: Capshore Photography)

Young People Working for Food Justice in North Carolina

Michael

Young Fishermen Are Struggling to Stay Afloat

Lucas Raymond holding a halibut. (Photo courtesy of the New England Young Fishermen's Alliance)

This Mother-Daughter Team Is Sharing Food Traditions from the Ho-Chunk Nation

Elena Terry, (left) and Zoe Fess smile after showcasing Seedy SassSquash, a signature family dish, during the Smithsonian’s