A Young Reader Weighs In: The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Young Reader’s Edition



Michael Pollan wrote The Omnivore’s Dilemma when I was too young to read it — honestly I may still be too young to read it at thirteen. The new version, the Young Readers Edition, is written for us kids. The book begins with a really great introduction that puts into words what you might be thinking: “I never gave much thought to where my food came from. I didn’t spend much time worrying about what I should and shouldn’t eat. Food came from the supermarket and as long as it tasted good, I ate it.” I felt that way in the beginning, too. It’s food, why worry about it. ‘People’ wouldn’t let us eat food that is bad for us, right? Unfortunately this is not the case, and Mr. Pollan’s book can help kids understand why.

The main section of the book discusses four very different kinds of meals and where the ingredients come from for each meal. You’ll be shocked after reading about where that meat comes from in your fast food cheeseburger. It’s gross. I bet in your mind you’re imagining a field where cows meander about eating grass. But all of the ingredients in that meal come from the “industrial” food system. What is an “industrial food system?” Good question. “This industry doesn’t look much like farming the way most people imagine it,” writes Mr. Pollan. “It’s more like a series of factories that turn raw materials into food products. It’s a giant food chain, the one that supplies most of the food Americans eat today.”

To me the worst part in the book describes how the “industrial” system treats animals. Because the industrial system is basically a factory, a machine, it treats the animals as if they were objects, not animals. Take scrambled eggs: the chickens that produced the eggs for those delish scrambled eggs are raised in a wire cage with barely enough space to turn around. There is no sunlight in the huge barn and there is no way for them to do the things that chickens do, like perch, scratch in the dirt, dust bathe, and spread their wings. Also because the birds are so cramped and stressed in this unnatural setting they tend to do things chickens don’t normally do. Mr. Pollan writes, “Pain, Suffering? Madness? Whatever you want to call it, some of the hens simply can’t take it.”

The next section of book is about “industrial organic” food. This is food grown on a massive industrial “farm” (I’d call it a factory), one of the main things that is different from non-organic industrial farming is that the crops are fertilized naturally instead of with synthetics. You might think after reading that, “well that’s not a lot better.” You are right, but at least with organic you aren’t eating pesticides or antibiotics! “I know the dinner I prepared contained little or no pesticides. Those chemicals have been proven to cause cancer, damage nerve cells and disrupt your endocrine system — your hormones,” writes Mr. Pollan. Think about it. If you are a teen I don’t think you want your food messing with your hormones. What’s best about industrial organic is that it makes more people think about the quality and impact of their food. Organic isn’t perfect, but it is better.

For the third meal Mr. Pollan travels to Joel Salatin’s Polyface farm, where they raise chickens, cows, turkeys and pigs on 450 acres.  This section just makes sense to me. Mr. Salatin respects all parts of his farm, the animals, the slaughter, the environment, the shoppers and the natural way things work. From the book: “It’s all connected… This farm is more like an organism than a machine.” Mr. Salatin’s animals do their natural thing and follow a cycle. For example he has his cows eat the grass in one field, then he moves them over to a new field and the chickens come in and help break the cow manure down, which fertilizes the grasses. This was my favorite section.

The fourth meal and section is called “Hunters and Gatherers.” This is a chapter on “finding” ingredients for a meal in nature. The idea can be intimidating. Like Mr. Pollan, who hunts his meat and collects wild mushrooms, I have gone to the local clam flats to dig up clams, collected warm blackberries from a secret spot, eaten a little bit of hunted venison, and gathered buckets of blueberries. It is really satisfying. Somehow when you work very hard to collect that ingredient it just tastes better.

In the afterward, Mr. Pollan discusses the power that we have to “vote with our fork.” If you tell your parents you don’t want to eat chicken that has been tortured, and your parents stop buying it, then the industrial chicken farmers will have to change their methods. In the section The Omnivore’s Solution: Some Tips for Eating, there are some really helpful things you can do, now that you know where food comes from. Following this, there is a Question and Answer section with Mr. Pollan. I love this part because the interviewer asks him questions you want to know the answers to. Then there are many pages of resources — lists of websites to visit, movies to see, and other books you might want to read. Some of my favorites he mentioned are The Vertical Farm Project, the film Nourish (check out the video Twinkies vs Carrot), the inspiring movie FRESH by Ana Joanes, King Corn, a documentary about how corn has invaded our supermarkets, and Food, Inc., my favorite movie because it really opened my eyes to where most of the food comes from in the supermarket.

After reading the book, I think you will agree that food matters. Does it matter to you that animals are tortured prior to being slaughtered? Does it matter to you if the food has pesticides on it? Pesticides have changed the sex of frogs — this matters to me. But guess what, you can make a difference! The first step is to understand where your food comes from, how your food was raised and where it was raised. Then tell your parents, tell the people who make your school lunch, and tell your friends what you know.

I have had many people say to me “I know all of that information and I don’t really want to change the way I eat.” One friend even said, “I don’t care about high fructose corn syrup at all, all I care about is that it tastes good.” The thing is, I think he actually would care if he knew more about it, and there are plenty of great tasting things that don’t have ingredients in them that are bad for kids. This book filled with great information, tips, pictures and stories that may challenge the way you are eating now. Don’t be intimidated. You want to know this information so you can make good decisions.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

View Comments (5)

  1. Joan Squeri
    Wednesday, January 6th, 2010
    Hey Orren, I'm writing from Cambridge, MA just after reading your review. I'm writing to say that I'm very impressed with how you absorbed the information In the Omnivore's Dilemma and conveyed the arguments to your readers. You clearly graspe the situation and are a very persuasive writer.
    I also loved the movie FRESH because it shows positively how things can change and some of the folks who are changing it.....
    Keep up the good work!
  2. Thursday, January 7th, 2010
    I am an OLD lady but I bought this book for myself. I knew I wouldn't have time to read the grownup version but wanted the jist of the information. I think it was done very well!