Taking the Plant's Point of View: The Botany of Desire on Film (VIDEO) | Civil Eats

Taking the Plant’s Point of View: The Botany of Desire on Film (VIDEO)

variedades_nativas_500

The Botany of Desire is not a political book. But as the author, Michael Pollan, said last Thursday in New York City at a debut of the film version (which airs tomorrow night on PBS at 8pm EST), it was the “sourdough starter” for the books that proceeded it, like The Omnivore’s Dilemma and In Defense of Food. Specifically, writing about potato production in the last quarter, which focuses on large scale agriculture and GMOs, was “the wake-up call” that led Mr. Pollan to understand that our food system is unsustainable.

The film is not necessarily supposed to be political, either. However, it does bring up a lot of questions about how we view our relationship to the plants featured: apples, tulips, cannabis, and potatoes. Primarily, the documentary focuses on how these plants used our desire for sweetness, beauty, intoxication and control to enable their propagation. But to propose that somehow plants have cultivated us is still revolutionary eight years after the book’s debut.

The director of the film, Michael Schwarz of Kikim Media, immediately saw the potential for a documentary upon receiving the manuscript from Pollan in 2000. When he ran into trouble seeking funding for a program that offered a different story about cannabis than that presented by the War on Drugs, one donor suggested they switch to wine grapes. But the duo stayed true to the story. “This seemed to me to be a really bad idea,” Mr. Pollan said, “in part because the marijuana section is really interesting, and also because what kind of message would that send?”

However, the cannabis section of the film focused specifically on what we have learned about the science of the brain from this drug, and felt much less risqué than the original text. By contrast, the final quarter of the film dealing with potatoes felt amplified, either in light of Mr. Pollan’s later works, or in comparison to the more historical focus of the apple and tulip sections of the film. Potatoes enabled the film to enter into the discussion of large scale versus small scale farming, monocultures and issues of food security (with a comparative look at the Irish potato famine, where the single type that farmers grew fell prey to disease and a million people starved while another million emigrated), and the debate over Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs).

Notably, the diverse audience at Asia Society that evening latched onto these controversies, asking some mundane questions (such as “How wide spread are GMOs?”) and some profound (Are GMOs fundamentally a flawed science, or do they have a proper application?) that Mr. Pollan, also the Knight Professor of Science Journalism at UC Berkeley, answered by discussing the history of GMOs as a policy decision, the European opposition versus the US acceptance of GMOs (they don’t trust their regulators, and we trust ours too blindly; the fact that our technology is being thrust onto them) and how to avoid buying them by shopping the perimeter of the grocery store.

It felt like the audience left more aware than they had come, and I had to wonder if indeed this film could be more effective at informing people about the food system simply because the dose was encased in engaging, beautiful imagery focused on a more profound message about who were are as humans.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

Check out the trailer for the film, below, and then watch it on PBS tomorrow night.

Image: Native Peruvian potato varieties. The film highlights the need for biodiversity in food systems.

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

Paula Crossfield is a founder and the Editor-at-large of Civil Eats. She is also a co-founder of the Food & Environment Reporting Network. Her reporting has been featured in The Nation, Gastronomica, Index Magazine, The New York Times and more, and she has been a contributing producer at The Leonard Lopate Show on New York Public Radio. An avid cook and gardener, she currently lives in Oakland. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Bob
    GMOs? I know you typically write to the earthy types who may know all the parlance and lingo, but some of us reading your blog for the first time get confused by the jargon. What is a GMO? And can you break out an acronym the first time you use it? Thanks in advance!
    • pcrossfield
      Bob,

      Thanks for the reminder. We do, in general try to do this, it was my mistake. I have now added the full wording.
  2. Great review. Thanks for drawing our attention to another extension of Pollan's array of creations.

More from

General

Featured

Popular

California Takes a Step Toward Restricting Bee-Killing Pesticides

Close-up of honey bee pollinating almond blossom in Northern California almond orchard. California contributes over 80% to the worldwide almond market with many of those almonds being grown in Butte County.

As the Infant Formula Shortage Drags On, Food and Farm Workers Focus on Breast-Feeding

Mother breastfeeding her son at home

How an American Crisis Brought Together US Dairy Farmers and Mexican Farmworkers

Ruth Conniff and the cover of her book, Milked, about the dairy industry and dairy workers

From Farmland to Frac Sand

An overhead view of US Silica's frac sand mine in La Salle County, Illinois. This mine is in front of Diane and Phil Gassman's home. (Photo courtesy of Ted Auch)