Message to the Slow Money Alliance: Time to Take the Plunge | Civil Eats

Message to the Slow Money Alliance: Time to Take the Plunge

I am have been sitting in the Slow Money Alliance conference in Santa Fe for a day and half now. Many of the pioneers in the good food movement have shared their stories and insights related to the current paradigm of wealth creation and its impact on the planet and its ecological systems. The overarching message that I hear is that we must reframe our sense of return on investment. We can no longer afford to expect huge financial returns when that means degradation of soil, plants, animals, humans and communities. We must broaden the spectrum of expected returns to include regeneration of human and community health. Health must be part of wealth.

I have been struck by lack of specificity in defining what the alternative return regime will look like. Several times yesterday, people asked in different ways: what kind of financial return shall we seek in Slow Money? In other words, in current market conditions, what can we – the good food movement of entrepreneurs – offer to investors that will still attract money? Several answers were offered indicating that clarity has not been reached. Tom Miller, a co-founder and board member of the Slow Money Alliance, said roughly, we cannot define that number. It depends. At one point, Slow Money’s primary founder and voice, Woody Tasch, said 4%. Kristine Martinez, founder of Angeles with Attitude, a Santa Fe based investor association, said it will be different based on the goals and desires of the businesses and investors. Eric Becker, vice president of Trillium Asset Management, a socially responsible investment entity, said the returns “will” be lower than market rate.

These answers are not the kind that seasoned, professional investors, who hold to the financial paradigm that currently predominates, like to hear. During this dialog among financial professionals seeking to create a new way to finance young companies, the audience became the most animated it would be all day. Why? Because this question of return and what is sustainable is the core of the question that Slow Money offers to all humans today.

For me it was a classic moment of paradigm shift. We cannot answer the new question using the old frames. Return on investment (ROI) is an old frame. It forces us to ask the question, what is capital? The first definition found on the web and offered by Google is “assets available for use in the production of further assets.” That is actually a nice definition, devoid of extraneous concepts like wealth accumulation, which is a value that has become a religion in our day. Slow Money is really asking us to question the current axiom that ROI or return on capital should be 20-25%, which is the rough average that venture capitalists seek because you will double your money every 3-4 years. Clearly, the Slow Money answers offered yesterday do not provide those returns. Slow Money is asking us to accumulate less wealth and to regenerate more health, but it has not clarified the spectrum of returns that can be captured in an investment product in a compelling way.

This reality clarifies that traditional investors are not likely to be the key to Slow Money’s future. Ari Derfel, founder of the restaurant/salon Terrain in Berkeley, actually called it out. He along with Kyra Pincheira, a young food entrepreneur said we need to look to a larger base of individuals who care less about a high return and care more about construction of new system. But as Greg Steltenpohl, founder of Odwalla and Adina beverage companies, said, working with dozens of small equity investors when starting a company is a good way to quickly burn out an entrepreneur trying to innovate. Starting a company is hard enough without answering to dozens of additional bosses, which equity investors become. So a financial intermediary is required, a means of aggregating the small investments of thousands of people seeking to fuel the needed innovation in the food system.

newsmatch banner 2022

Having been involved with Slow Money for several years now, I have heard many scenarios for start up. All have merit. All might work, but we cannot know for certain until we begin to implement. I hope that by the end of today it will become clear that this is the near term goal of the Slow Money Alliance. We will not actually get to the specificity required to make real the concept unless we wade into the deep pool of the unknown and actually begin to swim. Like the entrepreneurs Slow Money seeks to finance with supportive terms, Slow Money’s founders must become risk takers now to form a structure and begin aggregating money.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

Today’s food system is complex.

Invest in nonprofit journalism that tells the whole story.

Michael R. Dimock is president of Roots of Change, a “think and do tank” developing road maps to victory for the California food movement, and the strategic advisor to the California Food Policy Council. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

  1. Michael, had you voiced this sentiment at the meeting I'd have started a standing ovation. But alas, now I'm in the airport, flying home from Slow Money thinking to myself "I sure hope they do something tangible before the conference ends." Glad to know you are there to help make it happen.
  2. Deborah

    Thanks. I am hoping to be able to "call the question" this afternoon in the big session. I have spoken to many folks today one on one and many share our views. Some feel that it is still too early. We shall see.
  3. Michael, it's actually possible to get a HIGHER return by investing in companies that create a postive impact in the areas of Health, Wealth, Earth, Equality and Trust. Innovative companies who are poised to lead in these areas are already outpacing those still entrenched in the old "robber baron" mentality. Please see Paul Herman's work at www.HIPinvestor. Their stock index is beating the S&P 100. Full disclosure: I'm his wife - so I know how brilliant his analysis is ;-)
  4. Michael,

    I would have loved to attend Slow Money this year, and I wholeheartedly approve of everything the alliance is trying to accomplish. Clearly, the food system needs a shot in the arm and the more passionate visionaries that attack the problem, the better off we’ll all be.

    But, at the same time, visionaries occasionally need a dose of reality. Slow Money seeks to reinvent an awful lot, both the capital system and the food system, two of the largest industries in the world. Changing either of these industries, even miniscule amounts, requires massive amounts of investment capital. Consider this: opening one farmer’s market for every 20,000 people in this country would cost about $625 million. And that’s just a drop in the bucket when it comes to retooling the food system.

    To encourage mainstream investor interest in sustainable agriculture, NewSeed identifies profit-driven companies that have the potential to improve the agriculture industry—companies that do things like manufacture natural alternatives to pesticides and fertilizers, turn farm waste into energy, or distribute produce from family farms to major grocery chains—and tells their story to the investment community so that capital from Wall Street starts flowing in the right direction.

    The more “sustainable agriculture” is associated with low returns, the less private capital will be available to fund it. It’s that simple. A rational investor, whether it’s a hedge fund or a retiree, will always choose to invest money so that it generates the highest and most predictable return with the lowest risk. Our goal is to demonstrate that sustainable agriculture is an industry with tremendous growth prospects and talented professionals focused on generating market-rate investor returns.

    Next week in New York City, investors will converge at the first-ever Agriculture 2.0 conference to meet entrepreneurs and discuss commercial investment in this sector. We hope that this conference, in conjunction with positive momentum generated by Slow Money, focuses mainstream investor attention on an industry with better growth prospects than nearly all others.

    That’s the clear, compelling message NewSeed is trying to communicate.

    For more information, visit www.newseedadvisors.com/conference
  5. I was hoping that there would be an opportunity to present capital investment opportunities that do produce profit.

    I own an operate Coyote Creek Organic Feed Mill, in just three years we have gone from zero to $3.000,000 in sales and all the time being in the black.

    There is so much talk about how to increase organic farms. But, there was no opportunity for me to present my mill as an example. We are the only organic feed mill, not only in Texas but in the entire southern U.S.A.

    I am seventy-three years of age, and had no idea that this mill would flourish as it has.

    We have increased organic grain production in Texas by a large multiple. On the other side, the end product side there are many small family farms that are now producing organic; eggs, poultry, pork, turkeys, also, organic dairies, and the list goes on about how our mill has leveraged sustainable organic farms and farm production in just three short years.

    I want an equity partner who will join me to install professional management, and then build three more mills across the southern U.S.

    There is a huge pent up demand for organic feed. This in not and idea or a hunch, I took the risk and the proof is in the pudding.

    Now I just need some capital investorrs. I will furnish a Start-Up Coordinator, Construction Crews, Accounting and Inventory Control and Equipment location.

    I support the philanthropic aims of Slow Money, but I also want to keep in mind that there is a place for capital that expects a Return in Investment.

    Contact me if this is of interesnt to you.

    I am off to the Farm Fresh Dinner at the Santa Fe conference.

    Best wishes to you all,

    Jerry Cunningham
  6. Good to see so much comment related to this topic. There are fantastic developments in the private sector as both Janine and Jerry describe. I see their need to access capital and was disheartened by where we ended the conference. I am sure I am in a small minority, but it am an oldster in this realm and see the moment as so fertile for action. I hope to write a another post for Civil Eats by Monday that explains my disappointment, but that also clarifies my hope for the slow money concept. Hint: we need to take the memes and go for it. The Alliance will evangelize while others put the concepts to work. I know of at least 2 funds that were in the room that are looking for capital to put to work in communities, but we did not hear from them. It is my fervent hope to be proved as too skeptical. I saw the enthusiasm in Santa Fe and am glad, but see the need for more swift action in the field. The lack of clarity really left me wanting.
  7. Larry Yee
    Thanks for the candid report, Michael. The financial/economic system is hugely complex and we've been mired in a debt-ridden, consumption-driven, unfettered capitalism model/paradigm for 200-300 years. I believe Slow Money is on the right track, but to isolate and talk about what the ROI should be is like taking one cell out of an entire system and by focusing on it and changing it from the greed imposed levels of where it is to something different is the wrong approach in my opinion. I think we need to be trying to articulate what the principles of a new economic system should be and then figure out how it ought to be manifested in things like ROI. The "Prosperity w/o Growth" report out of the UK has some great concepts and Hermann Daly is on the right track proposing s steady-state economy. Onward

More from

General

Featured

David Montgomery and Anne Biklé, authors of

Soil Health Is Human Health

Soil-health pioneers David Montgomery & Anne Biklé discuss the nutrient benefits of regenerative practices, and how they may also be a solution to drought in the West.

Popular

A Young Oyster Farmer Carrying on the Family Business

Gaby Zlotkowsky on a boat holding a basket of oysters. (Photo credit: Capshore Photography)

Young People Working for Food Justice in North Carolina

Michael

Young Fishermen Are Struggling to Stay Afloat

Lucas Raymond holding a halibut. (Photo courtesy of the New England Young Fishermen's Alliance)

Young People Are Feeding the Effort to Unionize Food Service Workers

Starbucks employees and union organizers protest outside Starbucks headquarters in fall 2022. (Photo courtesy of Fern Potter)