Keeping Black Farmers in the Picture

If you haven’t heard much about black farmers recently, that might be because there aren’t many of them around. Or, as advocate Tanikka Cunningham put it recently, “If there was an endangered species list for farmers, black farmers would be at the top.”

Cunningham is the co-founder of Healthy Solutions, a fledgling Washington, DC-based organization working to bring awareness of black farmers to a national level, despite (or because of) the fact that they now make up less than one percent of all agricultural producers in this country. A former produce distributor who now works simultaneously to connect black farmers to markets while providing folks in low income neighborhoods with fresh produce, Cunningham and her group named last week, July 10-16, National Black Agriculture Awareness Week.

Pigford Lawsuit: A Mixed Blessing  

Black farmers made the national news near the end of last year when Congress, at long last, approved funding awarded in a class-action lawsuit filed in 1997 by 400 black farmers. Pigford v. Glickman (known to many as “Pigford”) proved that black farmers had been denied grants and other support by the USDA on the basis of race. The case resulted in the US government agreeing to pay $50,000 to farmers who could prove they had attempted to get USDA help but failed.

Only a moderate percentage of those who have applied have gotten paid, however. And, to make matters more complex, the media coverage of the lawsuit has led many to believe the problems black farmers face have all been solved. “People hear about Pigford money—something that did benefit some farmers, but definitely not all of them—and they’ll say, ‘Well, there is no problem because black farmers have money.’”

Furthermore, adds Cunningham, “A lot of people who are getting money are the heirs of farmers who are long since passed, and those heirs don’t have the tools or capacity to get back into agriculture.” She says she hears regularly from these heirs and other black land owners looking for support to begin growing food and existing farmers who work full-time off the farm and end up composting produce they can’t sell. That’s part why Healthy Solutions sets up farming trainings, works to engage youth in entrepreneurship programs in DC, and has established a cooperative for black farmers in the southeast.

The Soul of the Farm

Here in California, black farmers are less common than they are in the Southern states. But farmer Will Scott, known for heading up the California branch of the African-American Farmers Association, hopes to see that fact change. His association formed originally when a group of farmers gathered to fill out Pigford claims together in the 1990s. Today, he says, around 25 of the state’s 400 black farmers (from as far away as Bakersfield and Sacramento) have stayed engaged because they realize what a crucial moment this is—for farmers and the next generation of African Americans who run the risk of not seeing their culture reflected in contemporary agriculture.

Scott’s Fresno-based farm provides produce for several Bay Area farmers markets and restaurants  (including San Francisco’s Farmer Brown). He retired from an engineering job with AT&T a decade ago and relies on two younger brothers to help grow everything from fresh black-eyed peas to peppers and squash. “My sons and daughters don’t care for farming,” he says. “Most young people, their minds are elsewhere.”

Scott and his group (which does not yet have a Web presence) is in the process of establishing a 16-acre demonstration farm in Fresno, where, he says, “We’ll do training for small farmers and folks who are new to farming, and are interested in learning to grow vegetables. Everything from prepping the land to planting to harvesting.”

Urban-Rural Connection

Access to land is a common challenge for young farmers, and young black farmers are no different. Brent Walker, 31, is a graduate of the Center for Agroecology & Sustainable Food Systems program at UC Santa Cruz, and—while he’d like to farm a large piece of land outside the city—he’s found a niche in Oakland. Walker farmed for the People’s Grocery and now farms on two small vegetable plots for a food justice organization called Phat Beets.

“I wouldn’t want to be a conventional farmer, but organic farming really sparked my imagination,” says Walker. “Not to mention the fact that it’s a dying art.” He’s ended up staying in the city because, he says, “There’s so much energy in urban farming right now. And such a need in these parts of Oakland.”

This sentiment is one Will Scott well understands. “Urban farming is a good idea,” he adds. “We should be putting that land to use; if we had another catastrophe like Katrina, people would want to have that immediate access to food.”

 

This article originally appeared in the CUESA Newsletter.

Photo of Will Scott originally appeared in Edible San Francisco and was taken by Andrea Blum.

4 thoughts on “Keeping Black Farmers in the Picture

  1. Great spotlight here, that really hit home for me.I come from a family of farmer’s from outside Fresno and have been feeling at a lose that my family no longer has then means to keep to land they still own there. Maybe it’s time for me to get involved as more then just an international foodie.

  2. This is alarming. Regardless of color, “true” farming is being “killed off” slowly, but, surely.

    This country was founded, organized, and developed on the strength/backbone of our agriculture. Urban sprawl coupled with the continued growth of corporate farm operations is pushing our great heritage out.

    The fact that farmers of color are being lost at a higher rate is truly saddening. Eli Whitney, George Washington Carver, and a host of other black inventors/scientists literally transformed agriculture as well as our econony…the continuing decline of black farmers is/will be, a terrible loss.

    It is leading to an iconic heritage lost and a uniquely American history will cease to be written.

  3. This is a great point, I’ve heard it brought up before but I’m always glad when the topic re-emerges. There are so many tangled issues related to race and farming, such as the history of sharecropping and the fact that so much of the local farming buzz is related to internet access. Here in Baltimore, I am always trying to be aware of not closing out people who may not be on certain email lists or internet circles and making sure that all methods of communication (such as face to face conversations with the neighbors) are being used. At our urban homestead here in Baltimore we interact every day with our (mainly African-American) neighbors, and people are definitely getting excited and involved!

  4. The following report was widely cited in the family farm movement during the 1980s farm crisis: Pamela Browing, et al, “The Decline of Black Farming in America,” United States Commission on Civil Rights, Washington, D.C., 1982, which is available online as a pdf file.

    Much of the work on the main Black Farming issues has been led by the Federation of Southern Land Cooperatives, Land Assistance Project, a member of the National Family Farm Coalition. You can see video on this at You Tube, in “NFFC Farm Bill 1 Farm & Food Crisis”, and in parts 2 and 3. They support the issue I repeatedly raise, fair trade price floors and supply reduction (as needed) policies, along with price ceilings and reserve supplies. These policies were largely unknown in the food movement and mainstream media during work on the 2007/8 farm bill. They were the New Deal Policies, especially 1942-1952, when they were set at 90% of parity for living wage farm prices. During the 1980s they were brought back to life by the family farm movement, and voted on in Congress as the Harkin-Gephardt Farm Bill. Today it’s the Food from Family Farms Act of the National Family Farm Coalition.

    Another misunderstood issue is farm subsidies. The Federation conducted a major study of black farmers on this issue: U.S. Cotton Program & Black Cotton Farmers in the United States (online in 3 parts and linked through my name under Farm Bill Primer: More Depth: “FSLC-LAF African Amer. Cotton Study”). See also an op-ed on the subject, “Ensure that farmers receive a fair living wage”, (also linked through my name: “FSLC-LAF Price Floors Not Subsidy “Scapegoat”"). Without adequate price floors, they said they at least need subsidies, and not subsidy reductions (like they got in the 2008 farm bill, as cost of living/production increases were not included). Ending Direct Payments would therefore hurt black farmers, but what they really need is the Food from Family Farms Act, where no subsidies are needed with adequate price floors.