CBS Special Report on Antibiotics: An Antibiotic-Free Future for Animal Ag? (VIDEO)
February 11th, 2010 By Paula Crossfield
Katie Couric’s special report on the use of antibiotics in animal agriculture aired in two parts this week, exposing the intransigence of the industry.
In the report, Couric visits a confinement pig operation, where she speaks to a farmer who believes using antibiotics is necessary. She talks to victims of MRSA, a bacteria infection that is resistant to antibiotics. And she visits similar hog confinement operations in Denmark that are taking care of their animals without the use of antibiotics. The Danish are proud to have transitioned, and scientists go on the record to talk about the decrease in antibiotic resistance in humans since the ban in that country. At the end of the second segment, Couric is in a giant broad-breasted white turkey operation that has been antibiotic-free for 14 years–a barn filled with hundreds of birds that I would describe as crowded, and yet the farmer has managed to turn a better profit than he did using antibiotics.
Meanwhile, a veterinarian from the National Pork Board denies that antibiotics are being overused, and argues that costs for the farmer go up prohibitively when animals are given more space and not given antibiotics, and framed the cheap cost as a benefit for the consumer. However, at an extra cost of .05 cents per pound, Dr. Ellen Silbergeld argues its a price worth paying. What the National Pork Board neglects to mention is that on average, the consumer is willing to pay .20 cents more per pound for pork without antibiotics, increasing profits for farmers.
Farmers running these huge operations are in a difficult position, pinched by small margins and industry contracts that force them into debt to meet standards for confinement operation barns and equipment. They need more help to understand why the transition to antibiotic-free is actually better for them financially and health-wise in the long term.
Couric also interviews Dr. Joshua M. Sharfstein, the principle deputy commissioner of the FDA, who said, “The overuse of antibiotics on farms does pose a risk to human health.” He also spoke strongly for a ban on non-therapeutic antibiotic use in hearings on Preservation of Antibiotics for Medical Treatment Act (PAMTA). Perhaps Couric’s reporting will give congress an additional push to pass PAMTA.
Here’s part 1:
Part 2:
by Smokey
On February 11, 2010 at 9:53 pm
(from the post)…”Farmers running these huge operations are in a difficult position, pinched by small margins and industry contracts that force them into debt to meet standards for confinement operation barns and equipment. They need more help to understand why the transition to antibiotic-free is actually better for them financially and health-wise in the long term”
How about a hammer to the side of the head? It may knock some common sense into them… It only hurts for a day or two…a lot less pain than being held hostage to a buying system that puts them into huge debt and pays subsistence margins, of which they have no control over.
“Bigger, Better, Faster, Cheaper…not always true. There are actually better profit margins to producing meat from smaller herds with fewer “inputs” (overhead), it just requires a little more craftsmanship and effort.
I sometimes look at some people with true wide eyed wonder. But, then again, “I am the county nut”.
by Food Buzz: Antibiotics, Pasture and Childhood Obesity « Cold Cereal & Toast
On February 13, 2010 at 12:59 pm
[...] News special on antibiotic use in livestock. If you missed it, check out this brief overview from Civil Eats. I want to take this post as an opportunity to note the “current legislation pending in [...]
by Civil Eats » Blog Archive » Katie Couric Speaks with Eric Schlosser and Dr. David Kessler About Food Safety and More (VIDEO)
On February 17, 2010 at 4:00 am
[...] The topics ranged from portion sizes to school food, the push back from industry on Couric’s segment last week on non-therapeutic antibiotic use in agriculture, and to other issues of food policy and food safety. The discussion is nearly fifty minutes long, [...]
by Big Ag Poisons in the News | LivingSmall
On February 22, 2010 at 8:40 pm
[...] Maryn McKenna actually went to our family farm and interviewed my grandmother, who was put in isolation for months after surgery because she was an asymptomatic carrier of the MRSA infection. Maryn’s book, Superbug: The Fatal Menace of MRSAcomes out in March, and I can’t wait to get my hands on it (and not just because she wrote a nice portrait of my beloved grandmother and my favorite aunt). CBS has been doing a series on the same issue this week, including the encouraging news that when the Danes stopped feeding prophylactic antiobiotics to pigs, they saw antibiotic resistance in humans go down, and their pork industry saw an increase in business. Civil Eats has the roundup. [...]